Google This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project to make the world's books discoverable online. It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover. Marks, notations and other maiginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the publisher to a library and finally to you. Usage guidelines Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing tliis resource, we liave taken steps to prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying. We also ask that you: + Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for personal, non-commercial purposes. + Refrain fivm automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help. + Maintain attributionTht GoogXt "watermark" you see on each file is essential for in forming people about this project and helping them find additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it. + Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liabili^ can be quite severe. About Google Book Search Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web at |http: //books .google .com/I Bm^. Sib Tburas Bbovki. Km. brtrail prtserved in tlu Vestry -if St PMs-ii fir ^0 irr FRIEND G. W. W. FIKTH, Esq. (op nobwich), THIS VOLUME OF ESSAYS IS AFFECTIONATELY AND ADMIBINaLY DEDICATED. 443 PREFACE. I HE indulgent readet will be kind 4 enough to take tbe sub-title of tbese 5 Bibliographic Essays in a somewhat * restricted sense. The celebrated books discussed in them are widely known by name, but with the majori^ of them it ie by name only. And to the, general reader not only would their rarity be a hindrance to perusal, but, should he by chance procure them, the taak of wading through the thick folios might be found tiresome or distasteful. But here he may find something of great causes, men, and books, in a Tolnme which be can carry to the chimney comer or read on a journey, some- thing which it is hoped may induce him to seek after the treasures which lie hidden in the dnsty and often but dimly-remembered originals. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. BOOKS CONSULTED. Sumnta Hieohfficaj Sancti ThonuB Acquinatis Dimncb Voluntatis inter- pretis; Sctcrij Ordinig Pr^edicatorum. In qua eccleti4B CatholiMB doctrina univer$a et quicquid in veterum Patrum numumentis eat dignum ohservatu; quicquid etiam vel olim voaUum est, vel hodie vacatur ab hareticis in controversiam ; in omne ut erudite saUde, et dilucide ita pie atque Jideliter expKcaiur; in tres partes ab auctore suo digtrHntta, Parisiis, M.D.c.xxxyui. Bulter*8 Lives of the Saints. Dolmao, 1854, 12 vols. 8vo. vol. iii. 7th March. Article : S. Thomas of Aquioo, D.C. Penny CychpoBdia, Vol. xiii. Article: Aqainas. An Historical and Critical Dictionary. By Monsiesr Bayle. Vol. i. Article: Albertus Magnus ; other articles have been consulted. MeduBval Philosophy; or, a Treatise on Moral and Metctphysical Philosophy from the bih to the \4th Centuries. By Frederick Denison Maurice, M.A. London and Glasgow, 1848. Nouvelle Biographic G4nira2e, Article : St. Thomas D. Aquin. Philobiblon. By Richard de Bury, 1832. Notes to, on Aquinas. Miscellaneous Works of Pope. London, 1741. Memoirs of Mar- tinus Scriblerus, where a selection of theses is given in imitation of Aquinas's style. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. A.D. 1227—1274. U a huge brown Mo eometimeB ith, notliiDg less than the celebrated m " of Thomas Aquinas, which has i perfect harbour of reiiige for all Roman Catholic doubters erer eince it was written, and which has had its effect on Protestant minds, and will yet do 80, no doubt, for years to come. It contains somewhat more than eighteen hundred pages of closely-printed matter in double columns, and resolves, or affects to resolve — reaUy, to say the truth, it is lor the most part a very manly, pMn- spoken book — all the doubts, ethical, philosophical, or re- UgiouB, that a reader, be he priest or layman, can possibly entertain. This great work Aquinas did not live to finish ; but, like the Cathedral of Cologne, or the Ppamid of Cheops, althotfgh unfinished, it is still a wonder. Mr. Maurice, in fact, believes that, if Aquinas had conceived and entertained only half the doubts that he has ao boldly expressed, he would not have lived till ho waB thirty, much less till he 4 VAEIA. was nearly fifty. But these doubts never made a lodg- ment within his breast; and hence he was called the Angelic Doctor, as Bonaventm'a was named the Seraphic Doctor, He is full of calm consciousness of Faith. Those who rank him amongst the infidels, again to quote Mr. Maurice, can have but little acquaintance with his writings. Yet his book is a storehouse of infidel opinions. " The reasoner against almost any tenet of the Eoman Catholic Church can be furnished on a short notice with any kind of weapon out of the armoury of the great Doctor.'* * To return to our book. Infidel or not infidel, the Church has always regarded St, Thomas as one of its great doctors and champions ; and the very copper-plate .engraving which is inlaid in the title-page of my copy pictures what was at once almost a miracle and a conveyance to the Doctor of the applause and approval of his church. The Doctor is represented as kneeling in prayer, with his hands widely spread, and with a most humble expression of countenance; above him a little Cupid lifts from his studious brows his square doctor's cap, so that a nimbus, an aureole, a divine coronet of light, which, if we may believe artists, saints commonly wore, may have room to play, in a will-o'-the-wisp fashion, above his head. Before him, and in the midst of a large church of Palladian or Eoman architecture, appears the Saviour, in clouds, in the midst of which clouds also are certain cherubic angels, mere heads and wings disporting. From the mouth of the * Maurice's ** Medieeval Philosophy." THE ANQELIC DOCTOR. 5 Saviour issues a label, on which are the words of approval : " Bene scripsisti de me, Thoma ;" — " Well hast thou written concerning me, O Thomas." Perhaps the force of approval could no further go. We shall have to refer to this legend in the hfe of the saint, and may therefore, without further parley, proceed to consider who this great writer was; this great hull, this ox, the bellowing of whose learning has reached down the ages and affects us yet. The 7th of March is consecrated by the Roman Church to the memory of Saint Thomas of Aquino, doctor and confessor, by us known as Thomas Aquinas. Few men were more important in their day, and his reputation has not died out, but has been permanent and widely spread. The period to which he belonged was one of great mental activity ; of an activity, not to say restlessness, indeed, much greater than many of the modem school would be disposed to allow. The first dawn of the Reformation had not yet, it is true, become manifest, but a spirit of inquiry was prevalent, which was the sure precursor of an intellec- tual revolution. To quote Lord Brougham, speaking of a totally distinct but somewhat similar period : " The soldier might be abroad, but there was another person abroad who would make himself heard; yes! the schoolmaster was abroad; and while he was busy, what cared we for soldiers ?" The ancient philosophers and poets had again taken root in the human mind ; Aristotle had been called the enemy of Christianity ; Plato had been read, cited, and loved ; the Bible itself had been, to the priests at least, if 6 VAEIA. not to the laity, unlocked. There was also a great latitude of speculation; and, although not a learned age in the sense in which we now use the term, it is prohahle that there was much more originality of thought, if less of scholarship, than in the succeeding century. As before remarked, there was scarcely any formal opposition to the claims of the Eoman Catholic Church. But the thirteenth century was not distinguished by any exaggerated spirit of submission. In England our own King John yielded reluctantly to the Papal claims — a measure to which he was forced rather by his own extreme unpopularity than by any excess of sympathy on the part of his subjects with the spiritual power. In Germany the Swabian dynasty held the imperial crown for a long series of years, and the emperors of that family were engaged in constant strife with the court of Kome. Seldom had the person of the pontiff been viewed with less respect — seldom had he been hated so completely as a secular prince. The ecclesiastical power gained ascendency at last ; and the death of the young Conradin, and the accession of the house of Anjou to the throne of Naples, completed the niin of a dynasty fruitful in men of a restless and aspiring genius. Thomas of Aquino had not, as Shiel once said, that bitter chill of poverty in early youth from which the heart so seldom recovers. He was by birth one of the counts of Aquino, who ranked among the noblest families of Naples. "They were allied," says Alban Butler, with a pride which is perhaps pardonable, but certainly unchristian, " to THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 7 the Kings of Sicily and Aragon, to St. Lewis of France, and many other s(6yereign houses of Europe. Our saint's grandfather having married the sister of the Emperor Frederick I, he was himself grand-nephew to that prince, and second cousin to the Emperor Henry VI, and in the third degree to Frederick II. His father, Landulph, was Count of Acquino, and Lord of Loretto and Belcastro : his mother, Theodora, was daughter to the Count of Theate. The saint was bom towards the end of the year 1226, or at the beginning of the ensuing year ; for accounts differ. St. Austin obserres that the most tender age is subject to yarious passions, as of impatience, choler, jealousy, and spite, and the like, which appear in children. No such thing was seen in Thomas."* With such a sweet disposition, it was perhaps impossible not to make a saint ; with such a pedigree, so exalted a genealogy, it was very difficult to do so. The monastic life was the result of Thomas's own choice, but it was most vigorously opposed by all his family. The lustre of the long line of the Counts of Aquino was not, as they thought, to be dimmed by the dirty habits, the bare feet, and the serge gown of a priest. They little dreamed of the lustre that was to be shed upon it by the aureole of a saint. In early life the education of the child had been intrusted to the Benedictine monks of Monte Cassino. There is some dispute as to the share the Benedictines are * Alban Bauer's **Liye8 of the Sainte," vol. iiL pp. 43, 44. 8 VARIA, entitled to in haying secured so brilliant and acnte an in- tellect for the service of the Church J and, indeed, it would seem that he did not entirely determine to give up the world until he had resided some time at Naples ; when, after the lapse of a short time, he entered the order of Saint Dominic. This decisive step had been long opposed by the whole force of entreaty, persuasion, threat, trick, cajolery, and even force, of Aquinas's family. All manner of fond caresses, entreaties, and prayers were used by his mother to dissuade him from becoming a monk, and, says Butler, with a quaint sadness, '^ Nature made her eloquent and pathetic.'* His sisters, too, pleaded with her ; they omitted nothing that flesh and blood could inspire on such an occasion, and represented to him the danger of causing the death of his mother by grief. But nothing could move Thomas ; on the contrary, if we may credit his biographers, he rather moved his sisters than they him, for they both yielded to the force of his reasons for quit- ting the world, and by his persuasion devoted themselves to a sincere practice of piety. In sweet solitude, Thomas prepared himself for his future life in company with three books, a Bible, Aris- totle's Logics, and the works of the Master of the Sentences ; this quietude, however, enraged his brothers Landulph and Keynold, who were young and somewhat wild men, soldiers who had returned from the army of the emperor, and they sought to obtain that by force which the mother had failed to gain by entreaties ; they bore THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 9 away the young novice, tore up his habit, and shut him up in a solitary tower. Herein, like the philosopher of old, he was to undergo a strong temptation, and to succeed in overcoming it. But Alban Butler shall tell what this was : ** The devil suggested to these young officers a new artifice to prevent him from pursuing his vocation. They secretly introduced into his chamber one of the most beautiful and most insinuating young strumpets of the country, promising her a considerable reward in case she could draw him into sin ; she employed all the arms of Satan to succeed in so detestable a design. The saint, alarmed and afirighted at the danger, profoundly humbled himself, and cried out to God most earnestly for his pro- tection ; then snatching up a firebrand struck her with it and drove her out of his chamber. After this victory, not moved with pride, but blushing with confusion at having been so basely assaulted, he fell on his knees and thanked God for his merciful preservation." The story would hardly be complete without a vision. Falling asleep, he dreamt that two angels tied him round the loins with a cord, or, if we like it better, two angels did really visit him, and girded him so tightly with a cord that they awakened him and made him cry out. His guards ran in, but he kept the secret to himself. One heroic victory of this kind, adds Butler, sometimes obtains of God a recompense and a triumph. As St. Paul was let down from the city walls in a basket, so was Thomas from his tower by his sister, who knew that his mother, the countess, no longer opposed his being a monk. He 10 VAEIA. was received with joy by his brethren the Dominicans of Naples, and from that time he was suffered to pursue his desires in peace. Albertus Magnus was then teaching at Cologne^ and the two orders of St. Francis and St. Dominic were as yet in the full vigour of youth. Almost every man of intellect was in that day a priest, although perhaps only a priest in name ; and one cannot wonder at the unremitting watch- fulness and care with which his future career was marked out by the chiefs of this powerful spiritual corporation. The Benedictines, however, are no doubt entitled to some credit in forming the mind of the youthful aspirant. His biographers are never weary of boasting how pious and how modest he was from the time of his earliest youth. His great talent and gentle disposition seem to have attra<$ted considerable notice, and no pains were probably spared to secure such abilities for the service of the Church. Ee this as it may, St. Thomas of Aquino has been always recognized as one of the glories of the Dominican order. Under the care of the general of this order, he was sent to Paris, and from Paris to Cologne ; there he first listened to Albert the Great, a man small in stature and weak in body, but great indeed in mind. He ranked amongst the most learned men of the age, and was en- dowed with a wonderful vivacity and quickness of intellect. Like most of the learned of his day, he attempted to reach the extreme limits of the knowable, and to him was at- tached, in the minds of the vulgar at least, the credit of being a magician. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 11 iC I could easily belieye/' says Bayle, speaking of this charge^ '^ that, as he understood mathematics^ he had made a head the springs whereof might form some articulate sounds ; but what a folly to found an accusation of magic on this I"* Polydore Vergil, Pope Sylvester, Eobert of Lincoln, and Friar Bacon had like heads. Naude tells us that Albertus Magnus was more ingenious than these people ; for he formed a whole man, having worked for thrice ten years with the greatest diligence to forge him under the divers constellations, which the credulous reader, if he look into Old Moore's or Zadkiel's almanacs of the present day, will find govern the various parts of the body. Some of the writers of the time say that this man was made of flesh,t but by art, and not by nature ; a fact "judged impossible by modem writers/' It was called the Androis of Albertus Magnus ; and the tale is only introduced here because it is said, to his lionour, that Thomas Aquinas broke it in pieces, he being, we are told, " irritated at its great tittle-tattle." If any such figure did exist, more probably he did so from a belief that such an image was wickedly imagined and made. Albertus was accused of turning winter into spring, of possessing magical books, of being the first man-midwife, and, by certain magical performances, of preserving his own body from corruption. In a note Bayle quotes Father Raynaud, who asserts that St. Thomas never said that he broke the * Bajle*s Dictionary, article ''Albertus Magnus.*' t Bayle quotes Henri de Assia and Bartholomew Sybilla. 12 VARIA. brazen head of Albertus, and that the asserted miracles are false exaggerations or wholly fictitious.* Aquinas was, if not the favourite, the most celebrated scholar of Albertus ; . but, as Alban Butler tells us, his humility prevented him from showing how really advanced he was in learning. His fellow-scholars called him the Great Sicilian, the Dumb Ox. One day, however, the master observed, in the hearing of all, " We call him the great Sicilian ox, but that ox will make his lowings heard throughout Christendom." It is also said that one of his companions proposed, out of pity to his supposed inca- pacity, to go over his lessons and explain them to him. The saint submitted, through meekness, to this ari'ange- ment. It happened one day, however, that his friend found something which he was unable to understand, much less to explain. Thomas solved the difficulty in the most lucid manner, and his fellow-student hence- forward was content to learn from him. This story seems to accord with what we know of his character. Every allowance must be made for the tendency of ecclesiastical biographers to magnify the virtues of the spiritual hero whose character they are depicting. But, after making every possible deduction for party-spirit, enough remains to render it doubtful whether any of the doctors of the Reformed Church were actuated at any time by a more * Hyems in veris amcenitatem versa et caput SBnenm articulate luquens . . . sunt ableganda tanquam conficta et falso jac- tdta de tanto viro ; libri autem magicii suut supposititii, &c. THE ANQELIQ DOCTOR. 13 Christian spirit than that which inspired the Dominican monk, of whose life and works we are endeavouring to give some brief notice. His master, Albertus Magnus, was a man of very different character. He waa less of a theologian, and more of a philosopher. Some hints were occasionally thrown out, even in his lifetime, that he was an ardent student of the occult sciences. Being associated with the Angelic Doctor, St. Thomas, for so many years, he doubtless exer- cised great influence in the development of his young Mend's character, and this, perhaps, would account for many of the doubts expressed in Aquinas's great work. He survived his pupil seven years. A legend which was current concerning Albertus Magnus shows how widely he differed from the Angelic Doctor. Many years before his death he refrained from teaching. The reason for this was given in this wise : " When young, he had a diflficulty even in mastering the most elementary studies necessary for the ecclesiastical profession. He was almost in despair, when the Holy Virgin appeared to him and asked him in which branch of learning he most wished to excel ,t — ^in theology or in philosophy. Albert made choice of philosophy. His request was granted; but the Virgin added that, as a punishment for not choosing theology, before his death he would relapse into his former stupidity. This accord- ingly happened three years before his death. He sud- denly stopped short while he was delivering a lecture, and, being unable to collect his ideas, he at length under- 14 VARIA. stood that the time had airiTed wfaoi the predictioii should be iblfined." This stoiy is prohablj £d>o]oii]s ; we qoote it to show that, in the opinion of his age, Albertns Magnns was less a theologian than a jdulosopher. It was peihaps fortunate for his pnpil that sodi hi^peoed to be the case. Thomas Aqninas was of a devoot disposition, and had eyen some tendency to mjsticism. It is probable that his reasoning powers would scarodj hare been so fullj deye- loped as thej were, if he had not had a preceptor rather more secular in his inclinations than himself. After a few years Albertus Magnus was summoned to Paris, and his disciple Thomas accompanied him. In 1248 the Dominican order resolved to establish theolo- gical seminaries in various parts of Europe. Four of these were, Cologne, Montpellier, Bologna, and Oxford. Albertus Magnus was appointed to a professorship at Cologne, and Thomas Aquinas, being then twenty-two years of age, was also intrusted with the office of teacher. He now began to compose his first works, which con- sisted of conmientaries on the Ethics, and other philoso- phical works, of Aristotle. About this time he appears to have .been subject to fits of religious enthusiasm. In saying mass, according to Alban Butler, he seemed to be in raptures, and often quite dissolved in tears. It is therefore perhaps to this period of his life that we must assign the occasion of the miraculous vision which is illustrated, in the manner already described, on the title- THE ANQELIC DOCTOR, 15 page of the folio edition of the " Summa Theologiea." It should be premised, Tocco relates, according to Butler, that the vision took place somewhat later in the saint's life, when, indeed, he was at Naples, after haying composed the first part of his "Summa Theologica" at Bologna; certain it is, however, that, during the rapt and visionary state into which fervent prayer frequently threw this good man, Dominick Caserte " beheld him, while in fervent prayer, raised from the ground, and heard a voice from the crucifix directed to him in these words, ' Bene scrip- sisti de me, Thoma: quam mercedem accipies?' 'Non aliam, nbi te, Domine.' — * Well hast thou written of me, O Thomas: what reward wilt thou accept?' 'No other than thyself, O Lord,' said the devoted priest." Taking the story at its lowest possible value, and believing that, like the Egyptian priests, which Alban Butler tells his readers addressed their devotees from hollow cells made secretly behind the images, the priests at Naples imposed upon their devout and learned dupe in order to encourage him in his wonderful undertaking, we still must admire the sweet devotion and meekness of the rapt answer. In 1257, being then thirty-one years old, Aquinas was admitted Doctor at Paris. It had in the meantime not gone well with his family. The two young soldiers who had played the saint so scurvy a trick had become sincere penitents, and had left the emperor's service, who, in revenge, burnt Aquino and put Reynold, the younger of the two, to death, in the year 1250. After Aquinas was admitted doctor, the professors of the University of Paris, 16 VAEIA. then disputing about that for which their present successors would care very little, determined, in the year 1258, to consult Aquinas upon the ticklish point ^' of the accidents remaining really, or only in appearance, in the Blessed Sacrament of the Altar." The young Doctor, not puffed up by such an honour, wrote the treatise still extant, and laid it on the altar. While the saint remained in prayer on this occasion, some of his brethren saw him lifted up from the ground."* It is probable that while at Paris the whole mind of Aquinas, not given to devotion, was concentrated on his great book, the " Summa Theologica." There is a good story told of the simplicity of the man, the absence of mind of the scholar, and the fervour of the saint. The King of France, St. Lewis, had so great an esteem for the young Doctor that he often invited him to his table, and moreover consulted him in his affairs of state. Butler is careM to tell us that the saint avoided the honom^ of dining mih. the king as often as he could, and that when obliged to be at court, " appeared there as recollected (col- lected ?) as if in the convent," One day, dining with St. Lewis, the Doctor, with an energetic and triumphant movement, cried out, " Conclusum est contra Manichseos ;" " It is conclusively against the Manichees." The prior of the convent, astonished at these words, bade the priest be still, and remember where he was. The good king, however, fearful that the world might lose so valuable an * Alban Butler, " Lives of the Saints," vol. iii. p. 53. THE ANQELIG DOCTOR. 17 argument — for the Manichees were not overthrown every day — ^begged the saint to write it down, or, indeed, accord- ing to Tocco, caused his secretary to write it down for him. Eabelais, who in every story seized at once the point most open to ridicule, alludes to one regarding Aquinas, which Duchat supplies in the notes to the chapter (Pantagruel, book iii. chap. 2) where the allusion occurs. Pan urge delivers a lecture upon the wisdom of eating green com ; that is, of spending one's revenue before it is due. " I may very justly say of you, as Cato did of Albidius, who, after he had by a most extravagant expense wasted all his goods but one house, fairly set it on fire, that the better he might cry, Gonsummatum est! Even as since his time St. Thomas Aquinas did when he had eaten up the whole lamprey, although there was no neces- sity for it." This lamprey story arose from an incident at the table of St. Lewis. Thomas Aquinas was thereto invited. For the king there was served up a fine lamprey ; and, says Duchat, " Thomas, whom it seems no other time but that would serve to compose his hymn on the Holy Sacrament, had, at the profoundness of his meditation, eaten up the whole of the lamprey, which was designed for the king, and had made an end of this hymn and the fish both together. Thomas, overjoyed at having finished so elaborate a poem, cried out in an ecstasy, Consummatum est I ^ It is finished !' The company who had seen Thomas play a good knife, and lay about him to some tune, but knew nothing of his mental employment, fancied that these Latin words related to his gallant performance in demolish- p c 18 VARIA. ing the lamprey, and looked upon him as a very profane person for applying to a piece of unmannerly epicurism the words which each of them knew to he spoken by our Saviour when expiring on the cross."* There is yet another story equally good, and indeed, to a Protestant mind, more pregnant, which it is needless to say Alban Butler does not relate. One day, when the learned and saintly doctor was conversing with Pope Innocent IV, that Pontiff, on some money being brought in, probably some large sum which excited the Pope's pride, said, " You see that age of the Church is past, when she could say, * Silver and gold have I none.' " " Yes, holy father," an- swered Aquinas ; " and the day is also past when she could say to the paralytic, ' Take up thy bed, and walk.'" Aquinas seems to have been the acknowledged chief of his party and age. Whatever he did, he did well. He wrote in verse as well as in prose ; and some of the hymns yet sung in the Komish Church are by him. His works were numerous. His commentary on the four books of Peter Lombard, commonly caljed the Master of Sentences, is well known. As the claim of Thomas a Kempis to the authorship of the *' Imitatio Christi" is dis- puted, and indeed with great reason, so, perhaps with much less reason, is the claim of Aquinas to the authorship of the " Summa Theologica." But there is no doubt that the theological opinions of that work were his ; and perhaps the * Dachat, Notes to Rabelais' works. Translated by Sir Thomas Urquhart and Motleux. THE ANQELIG DOCTOR. 19 most important and most memorable of them is the saint's assertion of the supreme and irresistible efficacy of the Divine Grace. This doctrine, surely a biblical one, or, as our modem phraseology would have it, an evangelical one, wafi violently opposed by Duns Scotus ; and the followers of the two teachers disputed amongst themselves for ages, and do in fact dispute now, being ranked under the names of their respective leaders as Thomists and Scotists. In the year 1265 Pope Clement IV became head of the Church ; but this event produced no change in the regard shown by the Sovereign Pontiff for, or in the position of, Aquinas. The new Pope was a man distinguished by great conscientiousness, if we may judge from a letter written to one of his relations on his accession to the Papal chair ; and one of his first acts was to offer to Aquinas the Archbishopric of Naples. In 1269 Aquinas returned to Paris, but was soon per- suaded to revisit Italy, which he never again quitted. The Swabian dynasty had received its death-blow. The young Conradin had been executed on a public scaffold, in view of his own subjects and those of his family, and the for- tunes of the house of Aquino were in the ascendant. Charles of Anjou had little mildness or devotion in his character, and could have had but littie sympathy with a student and a devotee. He made, however, urgent en- treaties that Aquinas should return to Italy, and he, pro- bably influenced by his family, took up his final abode at Naples. It was not, however, for long ; hard study and incessant 20 VAEIA. labour, such as must have been undertaken to produce only one work out of many, the " Summa Theologica," had their natural effect upon the ascetic workman, which was probably hastened by devotional austerities. Not only was Aquinas a saint in his book and with his pen, but, not content with such work, with his voice and preaching he persuaded many. So earnest was he that the tears of the auditory flowed so abundantly that the preacher oftentimes was obliged to halt for awhile in his discourse. Nor did the wonders of the saint stop at mere oracular persuasion. William of Tocco, who relates that in his prayer Aquinas was lifted from earth, tells us that, as he one Sunday came from church, a woman touching merely the edge of his garment was cured. Two Rabbins were converted miraculously ; disputing with them one day, and agreeing to resume the argument on the morrow, Aquinas spent the night at the foot of the altar. The next morning his two most obstinate opponents came, not again to dispute, but to embrace the faith of which their interlocutor was so ardent a defender. In the year 1263, Aquinas had as- sisted at the fortieth general chapter of the Dominicans in London, and soon after had solicited and obtained his dis- missal from teaching, rejoicing inwardly to be once more a private religious man." From the sixth day of December, 1273, to that of his death, the seventh of March following, Aquinas acted as one with whom the world had passed away. He neither wrote nor dictated anything, but gave himself up entirely to private meditation. Pope Gregory X having called a THE ANQELIG DOCTOR. 21 general council, with the double purpose of extinguishing the Greek schism and raising succours to defend the Holy Land against the Saracens, a brief was directed to Aquinas ordering him to defend the faith against the Greek schismatics. But this was not to be. The council was appointed to meet on the 1st of May, 1274, at Lyons, and the ambassadors of Michael Pals&ologus, with the Greek prelates, were to be present. Aquinas, sick in body, set out on his journey, but was forced to stop at Fossa Nuova, a famous Cistercian abbey in the diocese of Terra- cina. Here, practising austerities which neither reason nor faith could demand in one over-pressed with fever, he prepared to die. As he was carried into the cloister whence he never went ahve, he repeated part of the 131st Psalm, — ** This is my rest for ages without end ;" and he had continually on his lips a pious sentence from the Confessions of St. Augustine, wherein that saint professes his hunger for heaven and the Lord. The monks begged the Angelic Doctor to dictate an exposition of the Canticles in imitation of St. Bernard. " Give me," said he, " but St. Bernard's spirit, and I will obey." He commenced, however, wearied out by the importunities of the monks, an exposition of " that most mysterious of all the divine books," the Canticles, but halted after a few lines, too weak to proceed any further. After having received absolution most piously, he desired the viaticum, and, to receive it, begged to be taken off his bed and laid in ashes on the floor. Then, in tears, and with the most tender devotion, he received the sacraments 22 VAEIA. and stammered out his belief. His last words, after thanks to the abbot and brethren, were in answer to the question " How one might always live faithful to God's grace.** '* R^st assured," said he, " that he who will always walk faithfully in His presence, always ready to give Him an account of his actions, shaU never be separated from Him by consenting to sin." After this came upon him the change we must all undergo ; he died in his forty-eighth year. He is described as a tall, well-proportioned man, active and of great endurance. His literary labour was immense ; not only are his works full of much thought, but they are so vast that they extend to nineteen foho volumes compactly printed. The " Summa Theologica" alone is a work which is astounding to con- template. Aquinas, a learned theological chief justice, hears the pros and cons, and pronounces judgment upon everything. His book is the great court of conscience, into which everything is brought. It resembles in some fashion Jeremy Taylor's " Ductor Dubitantium," but is written with much more boldness and less doubt. Aquinas never shuns anything; it is true that he always sums up favourably to religion, morality, and the Holy Soman Catholic Church : but there is no getting into holes and corners, and very little paltering with the truth. There is no doubt about the mind of the AngeUc Doctor : what he says he means and believes ; and the chances are that he made those who read him believe with him. It seems somewhat curious that Bishop Taylor did not refer to the work of Aquinas, in the preface to his THE ANOELIQ DOCTOR. 23 " Ductor Dubitantium," or the " Riile of Conscience in all her general measures, serring as a great instrument for the determination of cases of conscience" — a work dedicated, by the way, to one to whom it should have been of use, Charles II. But, though the two works provoke a remem- brance of each other, they are, in reality, very different. "Some of the Lutherans,'* says Taylor, "have indeed done something of this kind, which is well ; Balduinus, Bidenbachius, Dedekanus, Konig, and the abbreviator of Gerard. But yet one needs remain, and we cannot be well supplied out of the Eoman storehouses ; for, though there the staple is, and very many excellent things exposed to view, yet we have found the merchants to be deceivers, and the wares too often falsified."* He then quotes from Emanuel Sa, and remarks that the Romanists do up " so many boxes of poyson in their repositories under the same paintings and specious titles, that few can distinguish ministeries of health from those of death — for who can safely trust the guide that tells him *that it is no deadly thing to steal,' -f or privately to take a thing that is not great from one's father?" But the Eomanists had made a great advance in casuistry from the days of simple Thomas Aquinas, who for the most part palters not nor deceiveth, Nor is the golden- mouthed preacher, the sweet Shakespeare of divines, him- self free from too much casuistry. There is something * Preface to " Ductor Dubitantium," 3rd edition, 1665. ^ Emanuel Sa, Apbor. Y. Furtum. 24 VAEIA. about lying in his cases of conscience which might be ad- vantageous to a lawyer or to a careless witness^ but would surely be condemned by the judge. Equivocation, which our copy-books have long told us " is the worst of lies,'* Taylor tells us " may be allowed for great charity," and ia then '' only a crime when it is against justice and charity" — that is, he allows it. Certain it is, however, that we condone Taylor's offence when he tells us his stories; how one man, a Greek, saved his brother by saying he lay ou T? vXyi, " somewhere in the wood," when he had hid him under a wood-pile, and of another, Titius, father of Caius, who concealed his father in a tub, and told the cut- throats that pair em in doliolo lateri, the Latin for a little tub, meaning also a hill near Eome.* But if a man has a right to ask such questions, such as a magistrate, says our Ductor, we have no right to answer him ambigu- ously. Thus, if the magistrate asks if Titius be at home, we have no right to say Titius non est domi, the est leading to the inference Titius does not eat at home, using the word in a right sense, but in a sense less common. The bishop relates with great indignation also that story of a Spanish governor who promised a lady to give her her husband if she would submit to his desires. But, these ob- tained, the governor gives the husband indeed, but only his dead body newly slain. The lady complains, and tells her misfortune to Gonzaga, the Spanish general, who, finding it to be true, makes the governor marry the lady, that she * " Ductor Dubitautium," bk. iii. chap. 2, p. 500. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 2b might be recompensed by bis estate, and tben the same day causes the governor to lose bis bead, to pay, says the bishop, '^ for his dishonourable falsehood and bloudy lie. It waa a justice worthy of a great prince ; and the reward was justly paid to such cruel equivocation."* Leaving this disquisition, for which the story cited by Taylor from worthy John Chokier it is hoped will make amends, it may be as well to give the reader a specimen of Aquinas's work. It is one memorable and valuable for having survived countless mutations, ecclesiastical as well as temporal, and which really deserves the honour in which so many ages and scholars of such varied shades of faith have held it in. The " Summa Theologica " was, according to the author's own statement, written chiefly for the in- struction of young students of theology. It was adopted by the Church of Eome as a text-book, and from the first considered to be a most masterly exposition of theology. How little the lapse of centuries has diminished its repu- tation the following statement will show. The " Summa'' has never been a scarce book ; in one form or another it can«at any time be purchased for a mode- rate sum. The editions in one volume, folio, are perhaps the most common, but they are not we believe so old as those in five or six, large duodecimo. This form, however, is of little value in the eyes of the book-hunter. The first edition of the entire works of Thomas Aquinas was published at Rome, in 19 folio volumes, in 1570-71. This contains the • "Ductor Dubitantium," bk. iii. chap. 2, p. 502. 26 VARIA. only complete collection of his works. Portions of the " Summa " had been published long previously, but were usually sold at a high price. The best edition of the " Summa Theologica " is that published at Home (1773). It is beautifully printed, and, besides other matter, contains the commentaries of the celebrated Thomas de Vio, Cardinal Cajetan. A very pretty edition of the work has been lately published at Parma. In 1851-4 a translation was brought out by the Abbe Drioux. It seems to be very well executed, and has the formal com- mendations of his ecclesiastical superiors. Another version is in progress. It is well also to observe that a work entitled, '^ Summa, Sancti ThomsB hodiemis Academi- arum moribus accommodata sive Cursus Theologise juxta mentem Divi Thomje," has passed through several editions. I do not know what amount of circulation this work has enjoyed, or what amount of reputation it possesses. The fact of its having passed through several editions shows that it must possess some merit. Professor Maurice gives, in his " Mediaeval Philosophy," an elaborate analysis of the character rather than the con- tents of the " Summa," which latter really could not be well done in modem books, since it requires ^ve elaborate in- dexes to direct the reader to the various questions ; but Professor Maurice's aim is so different from that of the present writer, that he cannot quote from his work with advantage, or he would rather avail himself of the words of so careful a scholar than of his own. Let us take, therefore, the first question St. Thomas treats of; it will show his boldness, and serve us as well as any other. THE ANQELIC DOCTOR. 27 " The FmsT Question. Of the holy doctrine ; what it is and how far it extends : divided into ten articles. And as our intention is bounded within certain limits, it is first necessary to investigate the holy doctrine, what it is, and how far it does extend, about which there are these ten queries :— IT Primo, on the necessity of this doctrine. % Secundo, whether it be a science. % Tertio, whether it be one or many. T Quarto, whether it be speculative or practical. % Quinto, its comparison with other sciences. % Sexto, whether it be wisdom. % Septimo, whether God be its subject. % Octavo, whether it be argumentative. % Nono, whether it ought to be treated metaphorically or symbolically. % Whether the Holy Scriptures are to be expounded according to the many meanings (jplures sensns) of this doctrine." Taking up this, which very fitly opens his book, but of which modern readers who take the Bible as their guide will not care to know much, Aquinas puts his case, ad primum, to the first I answer ; then in another paragraph he adds, prceterea, moreover there is such and such to be said ; next he puts the contrary, and very fairly too, sed contra est ; and finally he sums up under the title Con- clusio. Each sentence he commences with, Bespondeo dicen- dum, I answer that it must be held. In his third aiticle. 28 VAEIA. whether there be a God, Utrum Deus sit, he is very bold ; nor is he less so when he takes up the question whether there be a soul, An sit anima. Indeed, this absorbing, wonderful question he chases up and down and into all sorts of holes and corners, proves that the soul is not of the body, triumphs over the Sadducees, and, in short, is in no way to be confounded with that scholar of our early dramatist,* who, after puzzling all night as to his soul's being, knew as little of it as his dog : — M Still my spaniel slept, And still I held converse with Zabarell, Aquinas, Scotus, and the musty saw Of Antick Donate : still my spaniel slept. Still on I went, first an sit anima ; Then, as it were mortal. O hold, hold; at that They're at brain buffets, fell by the ears amain Pell mell together ; still my spaniel slept. Then -whether it were corporal, or local, fixt, ^x traduce, but whether 't had free will Or no ; hot philosophers Stood banding factions, all so strongly propt, I staggered, knew not which was former part, But thought, quoted, read, observed, and pried, Stuft noting books : and still my spaniel slept. At length he wak'd and yawn*d ; and by yon sky, For aught I know, he knew as much as I." Had the scholar held, as he affirms, much converse with Aquinas, his doubts as to that knotty point, a point which Moses himself leaves untouched, would surely have been solved. For a careful reader of the " Summa " will agree * John Marston, author of the " Malcontent," &c. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 29 that the verdict of Mr. Maurice is not overrated. " So long," says that acute writer, " as we meet Aquinas on his own ground he is invincible. When you pass from him to the actual tumult of the conscience, and to the living facts of Scripture which respond to them, you are inclined to pronounce him utterly feeble.'' * Scarcely should we say utterly feeble, although the doctrine of the schools may be weak beside the after-ex- perience of life, or the teachings of the Bible. Aquinas does not shirk anything, as we have before hinted. Let us take, for example, Mr. Maurice's own account of his manner of treating the natural and human questions which occur to us aU concerning the power of God. There are seven articles in the first question on the nature of this power. " The third of these is, and it begs the question which Hume denied, that of miracles, thus; whether those things which are impossible to nature are possible to Grod?" Aquinas gives nine reasons for the negative opinion. The first is, that, since God is the mover of nature, he cannot act contrary to nature. The second is, that the first principle in all demonstration, that affirmatives and ne- gatives are not true, at the same time applies to nature, and that God cannot cause a negative and an affirmative to be true at the same time. The third article is very like the second : there are two principles subject to God — reason and nature ; but God cannot do anything which is impos- sible to reason, therefore he cannot do anything which is • Maurice's " Mediaeval Philosophy.** 30 VAEIA. in itself impossible to nature. The fourth is that what the false and the true are to knowledge, the possible and the impossible are to work; but that which is false in nature God cannot know, therefore what is impossible in nature God cannot work. The fifth is more noble, and perhaps more quibbling : what is proved of any one thing is proved of all similar things ; as, if it is demonstrated of one triangle that its three angles are equal to two right angles, that is true of all. But there is an impossibility in God, to wit, that he should be able 'to do a thing, and Tiot be able to do a thing ; therefore, if there is some im- possibility in nature which he cannot do, it would seem that he can do no impossibility. In support of this follow nine reasons, the ninth resting on quotations from Jerome, Augustine, and Aristotle. Then there are eight reasons on the other side ; and lastly, the Doctor himself appears. He has in this case to reply both to the defendant's counsel and to the plaintiff's, and he does this with the utmost skill, and finally delivers a verdict fi*om which the most orthodox will not dissent. All subjects he deals with in the same way, with great brevity, force, and conciseness. Let us now take one whole article as a specimen of the manner in which he deals with a question which has perhaps caused more blood- shed in, and scandal against, the Eoman Church than any other. THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 31 "ABTICIiB VIII. Whether infidels are to he compelled to embrace tJie faith. We DOW proceed to the eighth article.* It may be seen that infidels are by no means to be forced to embrace the faith. For we are told in the thirteenth of Matthew f that there was a certain husbandman" — (here, by the way, rendered by the word made so familiar by Punch, pater- familias), " in whose fields there were tares sown, and they sought of him, saying, * Whether shall we go and gather them ?' and he answered, * No ! lest by chance, as ye gather the tares, ye should also pull up the wheat.' And hereon, says Chrysostom, these things saith the Lord, prohibiting us to slay others. Nor is it right to slay heretics, because, if you kill them, many of the faithful saints {sanctorum) must also be overthrown ; therefore it seemeth, by a like reasoning, that the infidels are by no means to be compelled to embrace the faith. IT 2. Moreover, in the Decretals (dis. 45, c. De Judaeis) it is said, the Holy Synod has thus taught concerning the Jews, that none shall henceforward be brought to belief by force. Therefore, by a parity of reason, no other infi- dels are to be forced to believe. IT 3. Moreover, Augustin saith that no unwilling man * That is, of a series of questions all relating to the unfaithful, ad infideles ; thus Art. YII. is whether one may dispute publicly with infidels? Art. V. whether there be many kinds of infidelity? t Matt. xiii. 24, et seq. 32 VARIA. is able to believe, unless he first become willing ; but it is not possible to force the will; therefore infidels are not to be forced to believe. IF 4. Moreover, Ezekiel xviii. saith, speaking as if he were God {ex persond Dd), * I do not wish the death of a sinner;' and we ought, as we have before said, to con- form our will to the Divine will, therefore we ought not to wish that infidels should be killed. But, opposed to this, it is said, Luke xiv : * Go out into the highways and lanes, and compel them to come in, that my house may be filled ; ' now men, into the house of God, that is, into his Holy Church, enter by faith. Therefore, some are to be compelled to embrace the faith. Conclusion. Infidels who have never embraced the faith, such as Jews and' Oentil^f are by no means to be compelled to do so ; heretics and apostates are to be compelled, so that they may fulfil what they have promised, I ANSWER that it must be said that there are certain of the infidels who have never embraced the faith, and are by no means to be forced to do so, because to believe is an action of the will, yet they are to be compelled by the faithful if they have the means of doing so {si adsit faxnd- tas), that they hinder not the faith, either by blasphemy or false persuasion, or by open persecution. And it is on this account that the faithful soldiers of Christ often carry on war against the infidels, not indeed that they should THE ANQELIG DOCTOR. 33 compel them to believe (for when they have subdued them and hold them ca^ire, they leave them free to believe or not), but on this account, that they may force them not to hinder the propagation of the faith of Christ. Some, in- deed, are truly infidels who, when they, have embraced the faith, profess it merely as heretics and some as apostates, and these are indeed bodily to be forced and compelled, that they may fulfil what they have promised, and renew that which they once undertook." Then follow four paragraphs, headed, " Ad Primum," " Ad Secundum," &c, in which the same reasoning is repre- sented and insisted on. In the fourth and last the Angelic Doctor shows that Holy Mother Church, although she can be meek as a brooding dove to her golden couplets, also holds in her hand concealed thunder, ready to be launched at the heretics. "Ad Quartum. Since in the same epistle Augus- tin saith [he has just quoted the 48th epistle of Augustin], ' Not one of us wishes any of the heretics to perish ; but as the house of David could not have peace unless his son Absalom was slain in that war which he carried on against his father, so the Catholic Church, if she draws together a remnant {cceteros aliquorum) for perdition, soothes the grief of her maternal heart by the salvation of so many people.' " (2nd part of Part Second of the Summa, quest. 10, art. viij.) Almost every question taken up by Aquinas is of intense interest. Some of them, perhaps, seem to modern ears to be mere blasphemies, such is their plainness ; but the Angel of the Schools smoothes away difficulties, and generally 34 VABIA. manages to dedde rightly. Thus, in the second article of the seyenty-ninth question of his first part, he debates << Whether the act of sinning comes from God " — that is, in plainer language, whether Grod be guilty of sin. Of course he concludes that Grod is guiltless ; but he says that the will of God is the cause of the act of sinning (ergo voluntas Dei est causa actus peccati); and he sums up that the transgressor's act is necessary to God, but the defect is in the thing created. The whole of the question trenches upon the most delicate grounds, for which the utmost tact — and it is but fair to say that Aquinas has shown this — is necessary to prevent the writer from committing himself. The question is on the outward causes of sin ; and here the boldness of the faith of Aquinas, who, believing utterly and without doubt in the power of God, yet dared to impute to him evil, is much to be admired. He divides the causes of sin into four articles — ^first, from God ; secondly, from the devil ; thirdly, from man. " Et primd, ex parte Dei. Secundo, ex parte Diaboli. Tertio, ex parte hominis." And upon this he builds four questions : — " IF Prim6, whether God be the cause of sin ? IF Secundo, whether the sinful act be from God ? IF Tertio, whether God be the cause of blindness and hardness of heart. IF Quarto, whether these things be ordained for the salvation of those who are blind and hard-hearted." Let us turn to a less troublesome question. The Angelic Doctor seems to have thought woman inferior to man, and THE ANGELIC DOCTOR. 35 adopted, says Bajle, in a note on Dr. Simon Gediccus, Aristotle's opinion: "BLanc opinionem adoptavit Thomas," part I, quest. 92, art. and lib. 3, c. gentes ; but he was not rude enough to deny with the Italian cited by JBayle that women have no souls — ckt le donne non hahbino ant" ma — ^which the author, says the compiler of the " Historical Dictionary," endeavours to prove by several passages of the Holy Scriptures, and which he adapts to his fancy. As long as this book was printed only in Latin the Inquisition was silent ; but as soon as it was translated into Italian, they censured and prohibited it. On this opinion the ladies of Italy put a various construction. Some were sorry for having no souls, and for being ranked so much below men, who, for the future, would use them little better than beasts. Others seemed to be indifferent about the matter, and to look upon themselves as mere machines, de- signed to move their wheels so well as to make the men mad.* Of course the great bulk of the " Summa " concerns re- ligion and the soul. Theology is the very atmosphere which is necessary for the Existence of the Angel of the Schools ; but every now and then the thoughts seem more modem, and he debates subjects in a way somewhat similar to our modern essayists, treating of matters which concern the heart and mind. Thus the rules Aquinas lays down for the cultivation of memory are very good. The first is that we * Bajle, An Historical and Critical Dictionary. Article, Gediccns, p. 1394. 36 VARIA. are to call up some images, simtilaeray or likenesses of the things we wish to rememher, which are not to he too familiar, hecause those which are rarer excite our ad- miration the more, and the mind therefore dwells on them more fixedly. This, the Angelic Doctor would hare it, is the reason we rememher the things of our hojhood so well, and hence he places the seat of memory in the sensitive part of our nature. The second act he teUs us is to dispose of the things we wish to rememher in order, so that one may easily suggest another. The third rule he gives us is to connect the things we wish to" remember with our affec- tions, so that in very deed, as ^Ir. Maurice has it, we may Icam by heart. The fourth is that we are frequently to think and meditate on them, so that they should become habits of our mind, and a part of its very nature. Aquinas's treatment of hatred is thoughtful and philoso- phical, and would afford more than a hint to more rapid, and sometimes rabid, penmen, who think too little and who write too much. He asks six questions about it : — 1st. Whether the cause and object of hatred be evil. 2nd. Whether hatred be caused by love. 3rd. Whether hatred be stronger than love. 4th. Whether anybody can truly hate himself. 5th. Whether anybody can possibly hate the truth. 6th. Whether anybody can have a uni- versal and general hatred of everything and everybody. He sums up that hatred can be caused by love, although he gives three reasons against it, and says, '* Therefore love is not the cause of love ;" but immediately afterwards follow the stern words : — THE ANQELIC DOCTOR. 37 ** Sed contra est that which Augustin saith in the 14th book, ' De Civitate Dei/ that all affections spring from love. Therefore even hatred, when it is a certain affection of the mind, is caused by love." A verdict we feel dis- posed to agree with, hatred being often perverted love ; and certainly the hatred which Dr. Johnson, who loved a good hater, entertained against John Wilkes, sprang from the very love and deep reverence which Johnson bore to those things which Wilkes ridiculed and tried to harm. Looked at through the dim vista of six centuries, the life and works of Thomas Aquinas are whole, sound, and beautiful. Such a dedication of a soul to God one sees but rarely ; so great a faith, so sweet a humility, perhaps even more rarely still. Beautifrd are his unwavering faith and devotion and his manly ever-present courage. He had devoted his mind early to the Church, and he served her faithfully. Not without reason has his Church ranked him among her saints and holy men ; not unworthily does the Anglican Church bestow on him the title of learned. Sweet is it too, when ambition and gold, trade, place, title, and position, or even the tinkling of a literary name, have so large a share of the worship of the world, to turn to one who sat with kings as a simple monk, rapt in the questions of divinity or of the schook, imheeding the present pomp and ceremony, as well as the heavier and more substantial rewards of riches or of power. It would be idle to imagine that, in these days of rapid thinking and reading, many could be found who would sit 38 VARIA. down to study the works which are here glanced at. But enough, perhaps, has heen done to show that the scholar whose mind is engrossed in other pursuits may find much instruction and some amusement from an occasional perusal of a question or two as argued out hy St. Thomas. Compared with other writers, his style may he considered pleasant; and, although the phraseology of the schools is of course frequently introduced, yet, bearing in mind the sub- jects treated, and the immense range of ideas which were foreign to classical antiquity, it is even easy and flowing. Lastly, reverting with Professor Maurice to the saying of Albertus Magnus, we may well say that Aquinas has abun- dantly fulfilled his master's prophecy concerning him. The bellowings of that bull have been heard in all countries and in all generations. There is more than a feeble echo of them in our own. He has goyerned the schools And moulded the thoughts of nearly all Eoman Catholic students, and has given a shape to the speculations of numbers who have never read any of his writings, and to whom his name is rather a terror than an attraction. NOSTEADAMUS. BOOKS CONSULTED. Le Propheties de Michel de Nostredame, dont il y en a trois cens qui n^Ofit jamais encores jamais est^ imprimees. Troves, 1570 (?). Guir Pronosticon am den savant tneurbed Michel Nostredamus evit nas bloas, 8^c, Monhoulez (Morlaix, 1831). Extrait de Propheties des Centuries de M. Nostradamus touchant V6tat present des affaires, Extract von Prophecyen, 8^c, French and Dutch. Delft, 1688. Les Propheties de M* de Michel Nostredamtts, dont il y en a trois cens qtti n^ont jamais est4 imprimSes, ajoustees de nouveaupar le dit Autheur, (^Predictions admrables pour les ans cottrans en ce siecle, recueillies des mSmoires de feu Maistr. M, Nostradamus^. Par Y. Seve, Lyons, 1698. Le Propheties de M. M, Nostradamus^ dont il y en a trois cens qui n'ont jamcUs este imprimSes, ajoustees de nouveau,8^, S^c. Lyons, 1698. The Wizard ; or, the Whole Art of Divining Dreams, by the help of which persons, Sfc. on the principles of Nostradamus, 8;c, 1816. Le Bonheur Public, Prophetic de M. de M. 8^. Par Groranlt de St. Fargeau. Paris, 1848. Cabinet Edition of the Encyclopedia Metn^litana. Occult Sciences. Griffin and Co. 1860. Miraculous Prophecies, PrecUctions, and Strange Visions of sundry Eminent Men. London, 1794. M, Nostredame {Les Propheiks) ses Visions et Songes. Lyons, 1555, A. D. Nostradamus, some of the Eminent Prophecies of (no place of publi- cation). 1679. NOSTRADAMUS. A.D. IS03— 1566. sage who, witb the lower and non- giouB world — as djatinguished from that ich follows Dr. Gumming — deala chiefly prophecy, and who now-a-days makes a large income from prophetic almanacs, is thin year, perhapa, more lively than ever, and in his latest edition of "Zadkiel" boldly attacks the press for daring to assert that astrology was " ejcploded." " Who," he asks, " ex- ploded it?" and, receiving no answer to his question, he asserts that, because England does not believe in the voice of the stars, we see " among the poor want, misery, and indifference to Religion, Demons of Crime grovelling in vice— all the horrors of brutd ignorance, and the retro- grade march of dviljzation ; among the rich, bloated wealth, sinful and aoul-^nslaving lu:!ury, cruelty, oppres- sion, and harsh prindples of law advocated And the kingdoms of Europe, reaping no jruit from eiperience, but ever ready tfl obey the evil influences of the martial star, and pour out each other's hearts' blood ! 42 VARIA. These ! These abe the dole evils beafed fbom the modebx attempts to becby the science of astbo- LOGY." The capitals are the writer's own. But Zadkiel has a set-off against unbelief. He can- not only refer to the Tetrabiblos of Ptolemy, to Plato, Pythagoras, Nigidius Figulus, and Manilius, Bacon, Melancthon> Nostradamus, Al Hakim the Wise, and John Kepler ("here be names, we hope'*), but to the vast increase of believers of to-day. Cardinal Wiseman told us that, by the colportage system in France, from eight to nine millions of volumes were annually distributed ; but, finding '' that exploded fallacies " of astrology were still preserved as scientific truths in these books, "the Government wisely required a stamp," and, of 7600 works examined, three-fourths were rejected. It is possible, of course, that the Cardinal's friends wished to keep out some of the eorpZo^W' fallacies of Protestantism as well as "exploded fallacies " of astrology ; but Zadkiel chuckles over the free press in England, and, to show our superiority to France, gives the returns of the astrological almanacs in the fol- lowing list : — " Moore's Almanac sells about • . 600,000 Partridge's about .... 290,000 Zadkiel's about .... 65,000 Orion's, Old Moore's, and others . 60,000 Yearly total . . . 996,070 As each copy may be judged to be perused by six persons, this gives an aggregate number of readers not much below NOSTRADAMUS. 43 six millions ! what other branch of literature can surpass this?" (ZadMeVs Almanac for 1863). What, indeed ! Perhaps, after all — and this is the most melancholy part of the matter — ^these returns are not exaggerated by more than one-third, which, if so, leaves us four millions of astrological triflers, idlers, believers, or devotees, out of about ten millions of readers, if we may boast so many. If this be all that we have reached afler many years of teaching, the ardent scholar may well ask with Milton, " What boots it with incessant carQ strictly to meditate the thankless muse?" and may join with Zadkiel, £rom another point of view indeed, in lamenting the retrograde movement of civilization. Excepting, of course, Bacon and Kepler, many of the old disciples of astrology were mere puppets. Nostrada- mus has a sounding name, and he has certainly published twelve " centuries " (hundreds) of quatrains of prophecy ; but, after reading most of these carefully, we may fairly say that, out of the fifty thousand lines, more than half are so utterly mystical that they cannot be imderstood, and that, of the remainder, only about one-tenth can be applied. EQs art is much the same as that practised at the present day. A direct appUcation he seldom ^ves ; but it is fair to say — little as it may be — that an ardent believer in his prophetic spirit could twist, perhaps, twenty of his verses into some comprehensible application. It is very possible that no one else would agree to that application ; indeed, we always, with all prophets, want a key to the prophecy after it has occurred, and our modem soothsayers take 44 VABIA. care to supply us with one under the heading of prophe- cies fulfilled." Michel Nostradamus, a man prohahly of Jewish descent,* hut said to have heen of nohle family, " now only remem- bered," writes a biographer, " as the author of the most celebrated predictions published in modem times," was in his own day a skilful physician. He was bom on the 14th December, 1503. His father was a notary public, and his grandfather a physician. Michel, having studied at Montpellier, was driven away by the plague there in 1522 ; he then travelled, and, returning to Montpellier, took his degree. At Agen he became intimate with Julius Caesar Scaliger, whom he styles a Virgil in poetry, a Cicero in eloquence, and a Galen in medicine. His attachment to Scaliger induced him to make some stay in the town ; and he there married, but lost, at the end of four years, his wife and the children he had by her. Agen became insupportable to him, and, after having travelled for twelve years in Guienne, Languedoc, and Italy, he returned to Provence, and settled at Salon, where he married a lady of a very ancient family. He was invited, by a deputation of the inhabitants of Aix, to visit that town, in conse- quence of the plague occurring there, and was of such service, by the invention of a powder, that he received for * "II s'en glorifiait, et Tavait la pretention d'etre issu de la triba d'Issachar; il se faisait I'application de ces paroles de Para- lipom^nes," (I. 12, vers. 32), DeJUiis quoque Issachar, viri enuUti, qui noverunt singula tempora. Biographic Universelle, KosTSBDAlCB, par M. W — s. NOSTRADAMUS. 45 several years a pension in return. In 1547 he succeeded equaUy well in Lyons ; and, on returning to Salon, where he had settled, he employed himself, not only in com- pounding medicines, htit also in studying astrology and the ai"ts of divination and prophecy. The predictions he wrote at first in prose, hut afterwards, thinking better of the matter, he turned them into verse, and in 1555 pub- lished his first three centuries, with a bombastic dedication to his son Caesar, then an infant. Nostradamus did not forget to speak of himself and his .wonderful gift in this dedication, and, in a superstitious age, easily set the ball of his own fame rolling. Notwith- standing the proverb* that a prophet is but poorly received in his own country, the fame of the arch-seer grew to a very respectable height ; and, although many called him an impostor, others declared that ^^ his inspiration came from God," about which he himself appears to have had the least doubt of any. Catherine de Medicis, " the godless regent," who " trembled at a star," hearing of him, persuaded her son, Henry II, to send for him to Paris, where he was received graciously, and sent back to his own country "loaded with presents ; " that is, the king gave him two hundred crowns, and despatched him to Blois to foretell the des- tinies of the two royal children there. Encouraged by his success, he increased his quatrains to twelve centuries. Shortly afterwards, the king being slain at a tourna- ment, all the French world consulted the prophet's book of quatrains to find whether he had foretold the circum- 46 VABIA. stances. In the thirtj-fifth quatrain of the fifth century were found the following lines : — " Le lion jenne le vieu surmontera ; £n champ bellique par singulier dnel, Dans cage d*or lea yens lui crevera Deux plaies une, pins monrir ; mort cmelle !*' We presume that the golden cage in which the lion was to finish his existence referred to the gilded armour of the king, or the golden bars of the kingly helmet, which her- alds always represent front-faced and somewhat more open than that of a nobleman, certainly less protected than that of a simple esquire. Perhaps in modem days we may see the difficulty of fully adapting the prophecy ; but with the French of that day it was otherwise, and the prophet thereon became very much in request. Emmanuel, Duke of Savoy, and his wife, Margaret of France, honoured him with a visit ; Charles IX, on his progress through France, sent for him, and, it is said — the story is told of other astrologers — determined to put him to death, and asked him in bitter jesting if he could foretell the hour of his own death. "Sire," said the cunning physician, "the fates have withheld from me the exact hour of my death ; but, on consulting the stars, I found out thus much, that I shall die some very short time before your Majesty : our fates are inseparably connected. You will not long survive me." It need hardly be added that the superstitious king did not carry out his intention of slaying the astrologer. He was, indeed, appointed his physician in ordinary, and Henry presented him with a purse of two hundred crowns. His popularity having in the meantime been on the wane NOSTRADAMUS. 47 in Salon, he begged that he might be treated with more respect ; hereupon the king stated publicly that *' all ene- mies of the physician should be reckoned as his own/' Nostradamus - lived about sixteen months after this, dying on the 2nd of July, 1566. He was variously esti- mated as a rogue, a charlatan, a fool, an enthusiast, and a prophet. Even so lately as 1806 a M. Bouys published a defence of him,, in which he claims for him the merit of having foretold the death of our Charles I, that of the Due de Montmorency, son of Louis XIII, the persecution of the Christian Church in 1792, the elevation of Napoleon to the Empire, the duration of his reign, the fact (?) of his being equally powerful at sea and on land, and the con- quest of the Corsican hero by the English. ** The people of Salon," says M. Bouche,* " yet be- lieve that Nostradamus shut himself up alive in his tomb, with a lamp, paper, ink, pens, and books, and that he threatens with death any one who shall have the boldness to open it. This superstitious belief cannot but be very useful to the speculators who put forth new editions of the centuries of Nostradamus, with new quatrains adapted to recent events." " No one," says a believer in the subject of this paper, ^' should say that he has been at Salon without having visited the tomb of the great wizard. His monument may be seen at this day (1816). It is on the right hand of the traveller as he enters the door of the cloister^ against the wall. It is nothing more than a projection of marble of about a foot square, and about the height of a man ; ♦ « Essai BUT THistoire de Provence/' p. 69. 48 VARIA. the lower part is in the form of a slope, or shelve. Upon this tomb is the cast of the wise man ; it represents him as he was at the age of sixty-two, when he died; his coat of arms, together with that of his wife, is in a square of black cloth ; between this cast and that of his ladj is his epitaph, in Latin." Of this latter here follows a translation. On^will not fail to notice the similarity of the wish expressed on the tomb of Shakspere and on that of Nostradamus.. With him, as with Michael Scott, is buried his great book of spells ; and the verses of Scott, in the " Lay of the Last Minstrel," might be aptly quoted, should any one, like William of Deloraine, dare to profane his tomb : — *' It was iron clasped and iron bound, And he thought as he took it the dead man frown*d." HERE REST THE BONES OP THB ILLUSTRIOUS MICHAEL NOSTEADAMUS, The only one worthy in the judgment of all Mankind jto write, with his almost inspired pen, and according to THE DIRECTION OF THE STARS, The Events which should happen upon Earth. He lived to the age of 62 years, 6 months, and 6 days, And died at Salon, anno 1566. Beware you disturb not his repose I Anne Touche Gemelle, his wife, wishes eternal felicity TO HER Husband.* is * D. M. — Clarissimi ossa Michaelis Nostradami unicus omnium »» NOSTRADAMUS. 49 This Anne Touche Gemelle is said to have helped her husband on the way to eternal felicity bj having poisoned him. Let us hope that this story is^ as is most probable, untrue. Of course those curious about the matter of this paper will only consult the old editions of Lyons or Troyes, 1568, a small 8yo, and that of Amsterdam, a 12mo, 1668. There is an edition of his prophecies of which political capital was largely made against Cardinal Mazarin. This is its title and date, "Les Vraies Centuries de Michel Nostradamus expliquees sur les affaires de ce temps, 1652." The prophet of Salon had, like most men who have attained any celebrity, his opponents as well as supporters. Ant* Coullard wrote bitterly against him, and Conrad Badius published in 1562 a satire in verse against him, entitled " Les Vertus de notre Maitre Nostradamus." But if one or two attacked him, hundreds have defended him. One man wrote a commentary on his quatrains, another pub- lished a concordance to them,* and so late as 1806 Theo- dore Bouys published with reference to him " New Consi- derations based upon the instinctive Clairvoyance of Man, on Oracles, Sybilles, Prophecies, and particularly on Nos- tradamus." Here is the prediction about our Charles I, which is at jndicio digni cujiis penb divino calamo totios orbis ex Astrorum in- flaza futnri eventns conscriberetur, &€. The name of his wife is given as Anna Pontia Gemella, a native of Salon. ♦ ** Concordance dea Proph^ties de N" , avec histoire." Guy- naud, 1693. £ 60 VABIA. least singular from having been written and printed in the year 1598 :— "Gaad et Brnzelles marcheroxit contra Anvers; S^nat de Londres mettront k mort lenr Roi ; Le sel et le via lui seront k Penvers, Pour eux avoir regn^ en d^sarroi.'* The one which follows, however, is yet more so. In dedicating his work to Henry II, Nostradamus told that sovereign that the Church of Eome would suffer much persecution, '^ et durera ceste cy jusques a I'an mille sept- cent nonante deux, que I'on cuidera estre une renovation de si^cle." To appreciate the force of this prediction it is necessary to remember that in 1792 (Sept. 22) the French Eepublic decreed the abolition of the old method of measuring time from the birth of Christ, and that all public acts were to be reckoned from the new era — in fact, from the year One. But, in spite of these lucky guesses, the major part of the quatrains of Nostradamus are to us as incomprehen- sible as "Hebrew-Greek" was to Sir John FaJstaff. What, for instance, can we understand by this, which relates to our own land ? ** Le Grand Empire fera par AngleterrOj Le Pempotam des ans plus an trois cents ; Grands copies passee par mer et terre, Les Lusitans n'en feront pas contens." Does it relate to the dissatisfaction which Portugal felt, and perhaps now feels, at the success of England's colonies? Again, to what Grecian princess does this allude ?— N0STBABAMU8. 51 '' La dame Griacque de beaat^ aydigae, Henrense faits de ports innumerable, Hors translate en regne Hispaniqne, Captive prinse, mourir mort miserable." This is the seventy-eighth quatrain of the ninth century^ In the following one, printed, as all the other extracts from the hook, verbatim et literatim, many have pretended to see a prophecy of the death of Louis XVI : — '* Pluye, Faim, Guerre en Perse non cess^e, La foy trop grand trabiri le monarqne ; Par finie en Ganle commenc^e^ Secret angaste poor a an estre parqne.*' '' The Rain, Famine, War in Persia not being ended, Too great credulity shall betray the monarch ; Being ended there, it shall begin in Franccy A secret omen to one that he shall die.** The English translator in 1794 adds, " No sooner had a peace been settled between Lord Comwallis and Tippoo Saib, than war was declared against France, which proves a striking instance of the truth of this prediction." Louis XVI. was put to death in 1793. The next that we have to present to the reader forms one, we presume, amongst the many which may have had a partial fulfilment ; or, on the other hand, mayhap it has yet to come to pass ; for it is a striking beauty in Nostradamus, as well as in other prophets, that their predictions are so widely made that, if not applicable to one person or age, they are open to fit another. To take an instance, the modern, so-called " Zadkiel " having, as it happens, last year prophesied the 62 VARIA. death of Lord Eussell^ and several others whose great age would naturally scarcely require a prophet to foretell a proximate decease, to-day eats his own words, and declares that the application was wrongly made, and that, if the Prime Minister do not die this year, he will " come to much honour in Octoher or November next." " Truly, there is much virtue in an ' if.' " This is the quatrain to which we allude : — *' Regne GaaloU tn seras chang^, £a lieu estrange est translate I'Empire, En autre moeurs et lois feras rang4, Bouan et Chartres te feront bien du pire.'* Of course Nostradamus has been put to other political use than that of fulminating against Cardinal Mazarin. In 1848, when all the French papers were flattering the French Republic and the French people, a cer- tain M. Girault de Saint-Fargeau published a folio broadside called "Le Bonheur Public," a prophecy of Michel Nostradamus. This " public good " is a curious paper, and the prophecy translated and given to it by M. Saint-Fargeau, who has also Frenchified the style so as to render it more readily understandable (" dont on a frandse le style pour le rendre plus facile a comprendre "), is certainly the largest ever made by Michel. The clumsi- ness in which the style is Frenchified is apparent to all* The writer goes into statistics, and gives us a crowd of figures, budgets of expenses. Justice, Worship, Public Instruction, and Foreign Affairs. In it three gi'eat French Revolutions are predicted— 1793, 1848, and 1998. There was to be NOSTRADAMUS. 63 the abolition of the punishment of death, and a general dis- armament in 1860 by the decision of a congress of all the States of Europe. .Twenty-five thousand colonists were to he yearly gratuitously deported from France, and in return these grateful colonists would send trees, grain, vegetables, and animals susceptible of being naturalized in France, and fit also for increasing the means of nourishment for those at home, and to enlarge the comfortable existence (hien-Stre) of the indigenous population. . After having discoursed considerably about matters con- nected rather with industrial exhibitions and public work- shops than with anything else, this gentleman who ^'frenchi- fiea" old Nostradamus exhausts his broadside, and then tells us that the manuscript — ^which, by the way, was taken in 1847 finom the tomb of Nostradamus, at Salon, in the arron- dissement of Aix, department of Bouches-du-Ehone — be- gins to get. imperfect, and offers more than one gap to the reader, since the last page has been spoilt by the damp. ** Jt is with great trouble," says the romancist, *^ that we can. decipher the following: — ^^ ^ . • • Europe ... La France the capital . • , • civilized world • . . . natural limits the Bhine, the Alps and the Pyrenees , • • ' " Most readers will remark here, that, as the proverbial nod is as good as a wink, the damp has done not so much harm. We are told that we can manage to fill up these lacunse. The prophecies, indeed, are rather improved than ^' deterior^s par I'humidit^." At least so says M. G. de Saint-Fargeau. Let us go on : — 54 ' VAItlA. ; but we do not know what we have yet to come to— • " * To Sweden will be united Finland and the district of Saint Petersburg, of which the town of that name will become the capital . . . The Bussians . . . pushed back beyond . . , Dnieper . . • Poland . . . extends to the Black Sea on the south . . - « to the Baltic between the Vistula and Dwina on the north.':'^.. ' . 4 Beally the, damp has been very obliging to the prophet. '^^ Criniea, Oircassia and Georgia . • • from . • « descendants of Schamyl . . . Turks . . , swept back into Asia . . » .. Greece, Candia, Bulgaria, Albania j Boiimelia . . . . Moldavia and Wallachia . . of which Constantinople is the capital • . Italy a federation . , . . . Sicily, Naples, States. of the Church, Lombardy,. Piedmont.' " .... Nostradamus, in truth, in 1847, knew something. If he only comes as near the truth with us as he has done with others, farewell England ! " * L'Angleterre . . * whose colonies have, been long made free ... will renounce her Indian posses- sions ., ., . reduced to the part which her insular position assigns to her . ■ ... m consequence of the NOSTRADAMUS. 55 immense development of the commercial navies of the two Americas . . .'" Equally as genuine as the above extracts, so far as having been written by Nostradamus, are the following lines on the signification of dreams, extracted from the mighty book of Nostradamus which, we were told, in 1816,* was iron-clasped and iron-bound, and therefore had not suffered £rom damp. « AbtejMe. To dream of any absent friend Will news of them or ill portend ; And if at thy bed-aide they seem, Their death, perhaps, may solve thy dream. The above is dogmatic ; those which follow are according to the fashion of interpreters of dreams from Joseph down- wards — merely symbolic, or simply p«r emtra. Anchor. See an anchor in yr dream And certain hope and comfort beam. Bees. Bees in your dream good friends imply, Who*ll serve you most indnstrionsly ; But, if bees sting, it plainly shows That thou haat busy active foes* Bdhf. To dream one's belly 's large and great Predicts a fair and large estate. Does it? In the name of Sir John Falstaff, that ton of^ man, why so? should it not rather predict dropsy? BuUs, To dream of bulls is dread and drear : Some enemies be sure are near. * The Wizard, p. 15. S^e list of books consulted. 56 VABIA, (hradle, A cradle means, to maid or wife, A joyful but a busy life. Coach. Dream that you in a carriage ride And poverty shall lower pride. Death. To dream of death a marriage means ; So variegated are life's scenes. Sand, To dream a cold hand is put to you in bed. Your next news will be a relation is dead. Onions, To dream of eating onions means Mnch strife in thy domestic scenes« Faper* To dream that yon on paper write Denotes accusers, hate and spite. SUver, To dream of silver means deceit : The slippery coin's an emblem meet. Virgin, A virgin discoursing is good in a dream, Joy and delight on your house shall beam. Wound* To dream of a wound is sorrow and grief: Of dressing a wound is cure or relief. Writing, Dreaming of writing ever means news 'TwHl grant or deny, will give or refuse. V After this, who will deny the wisdom of our ancestors? As I am unable to find the original of the above " choice " productions^ it would be absurd to give IS'ostradamus the credit of them. IN'ostradamus was, of course, a weather prophet, and pubUshed daring several years an almanac and many other works, most of them medical, of which the names only are remembered. A famous Latin distich, attributed to Beza^ and also to Jodelle^ contains as much good sense NOSTRADAMUS. 57 as it does point, and is worthy to be remembered in connection with this prophet. " Nostra damns, cbm. falsa damns, nam fallere nostra est ; £t ctun falsa damns, nil nisi nostra damns.** A townsman of Michel has published an abridgment of his life^ and Adelung has placed him amongst his portraits in the *' Histoire de la Folie Humaine/' a work which, if it were fully done, would be of the driest and most melan- choly reading, but surely, also, a story without an end. It is questionable whether there be any belieyers in the prophet now alive ; still, many astrologers and alchemists buy their books of Mr. Millard, in Newgate-street ; and, as we hare yet amongst us those who believe in Joanna Southcote and her Shiloh, there may also be those who puzzle their bemused brains over the Centuries of Michel l^ostradamus. THOMAS A KEMPIS AND THE IMITATIO CHRISTI. •u^Sv BOOKS CONStriTED. De Imiiaiume Christi et Omtewygtu MtauU omnitimque tjns vcauiattan. Codex de Adooeatit Saculi ziii. Londini, apud Guil. Pickering, 1851. Imitatum de J^sus- Christ, Traduction Nouodle, Sur V Edition Latine de 1764. Bewe sur huU MmuscripU, Par M. L'Abb^ Valart MDCCLXVI. The Christian's Pattern ; or, A Treatise of the Imitation of Christ. Li foar books. Bj George Stanhope, D.D., Chaplain in Ordinary to His Majesty. Ninth edition. 1714. DerimitcOionde Noire' Seigneur JisHS'Christ, Par Jean Geraon, Ohancelier de I'Universit^ de Paris. Tradoite en Fran9ais, en GreCy en Anglais, en Allemand, en Italien, en Espagnol, et en Portngais ; (texte Latin en regarde). Pabli6e sous la direction de J. B. Monfalcon. Lyon, 1841. Imitation of Christ, A new translation. Boms, London, 1856. Imitation of Christ. New edition. 12mo. J. H. & J. Parker, liondon, 1861. Sunday at Home, Part for November, 1865. THOMAS A KEMPIS AND THE IMITATIO CHRI8TL QneiBperfectljawaretbatjOfallpoptdar I, popular in the beet seuBe, and iridelj d in the fullest, the ImUatio ChrUti a first ; when we call to mind that Dr. Johnson s^d of it that it had gone through more editjons than there had been months since its publication — it maj seem auomalona to place it amongst the rare books. But there are drcumstances which render ils position here perfectly legitimate. The history of the book is cmioas, and almost every one who reads it becomes ^ther a Kempisian or an anti-Eempisian, or, in a special sense, a Tbomist, or an anti-Thomist. Last year an edition* was published in which the present writer gave a full account of the three claimants to the anthorship of Ihe celebrated book, Jean Gerson, Jean Gersen, and Thomas the Monk of A Eempis, whom scholars now generally presume to have been a mere copyist. Yet, writing some months after 62 VARFA. this pabHcation^ Andrew Thomson, D.D., states, in ah article in the ^'Sunday Magazine," that the weight of evidence is in favour of A Kempis, and, stranger still, that " Genm " is merdy an alteration of" Gerson !" Here are his words : — " The earliest edition of this religious treatise carries us back through nearly four centuries, or a hundred years beyond the Beformation. In the intervening ages, it is affirmed to have been translated into sixty different lan- guages, and to have passed through 1800 editions, and probably to have been more read than any other religious book, the Bible alone excepted. And that it has in no degree been indebted to external circumstances connected with its composition for the hold which it retains of human interest, may be concluded from the fact, that its author- ship was, for many ages, the subject of as much discussion as that of the celebrated letters of Junius, and that the controversial works which have been expended on this one subject have occupied a hundred times more space than the original work itself. It became a national question be- tween the learned schools of different countries ; and uni- versities ranged themselves on the side of opposite claimants. The theologians and literary men of France generally con- tended that Thomas-a-Kempis was merely the transcriber of the book, and that John Gerson, a famous chancellor of the University of Paris, was its real author. Others put forward the name of John Gersen, whose name has been found attached to one manuscript; but one is stnyngly temjpted to suspect that this is only a slight misnomer for THOMAS A KEMPIS. 63 the CTumeeUor, The Gknaan and Flemish writers who entered the lists in this long-pending discussion^ declared themselyes on the side of A-Kempis> and were ultimatelj supported by the powerful authority of the Sorbonne. The external evidence on the side of the two principal claimants seems nearly equal ; but not to speak of a very distinct line of unbrokoi tradition, the internal eridence turns the scale in favour of A-Kempis ; for Gerson was never the inmate of a monastery, which Thomas-ii-Kempis was for seventy years, and the whole composition bears the indubitable mark of monastic life, and evidently comes from the pen of a solitary, though kind-hearted ascetic." The '^distinctline of unhrohen tradition," alas ! is so faint that the good doctor would find it hard to trace. Kempis was a '^ copying" monk ; mauy works are known to have — ^to use a penny-a-liner's phrase — " proceeded from his pen," amongst others, several testaments, old and new ; but no one ever accused him of writing those books. M. Gence has described the manuscript of 1425, on which all A Kempis's claims rest, and all that is therein is this : that there is on the MS. a note in a strange hand, in Latin, in which note we are told that it is '^ to be under- stood that this tractate was written by the upright and ex- cellent man, Thomas, of Mount St. Agnes, called Thomas de Kempis ; it was written by the hand of the author in 1425." But this anonymous note, as the editor of the French Polyglot says, proves nothing.* Nothing, certainly, * Pr^sente-t-il da moins rdvidence positive de la date de sa 64 VABIA. in favour of A Kempis ; ^but it intemallj proves this, that the note was not written by A Kempis if he were Ihe author. Surely the writer of " Like unto Christ" would never call himseU prohus et egregius vir. As for the links of unbroken tradition^ we do not really know where they are. Thomas Dibdin, M.A., a good bibliopolidt and a scholar, thought that descrijptus ex manu might be read as " copied out by," and tells us that which the translator of the latest edition does, that only solitary books ever bore A Kempis's name. The edition which attributed the book to A Kempis is called by M. Monfalcon the editio prin- ceps (he doubts with Dibdin and Gence the edition of 1468), and was printed in 1472. But in 1474 we have a certain edition assigning the book to John Gerson ! And there is an edition without date, which M. de Gregory places to the year 1470, on the testimony of an old catalogue which bears this title, <&«, '^ De Imitatione Christi. . . Incipit liber Magistri Johannis Gerson de Imitatione Christi." Nay, in 1481 there is an edition which attributes the work to St. Bernard. *^ Incipit opus composition en 1425? Non sans donte. Cette date est-elle inscrite sor le mannscrit lui-meme, et de la main qui a transcrit le texte ? Point de tout : elle se trouve dans une note anouyme et bien ^yidem- ment 6crite par une main ^trangere. La voici : — '* Notandum quod iste tractatus editus est a probo et egregio viro magiatro TTioma de Monte SanctiB Agnetis et canonicoregulari in Trajeeto Thomas de Kem- pis dictus, descriptus ex manu auctoris in Trajeeto^ anno 1425, m societatu provincialatus," Cette note anonyme, et d'un main 6trangfere, ne saurait done avoir Tautorit^ du manuscrit lui-meme." J. B. Monfalcon, De VAuteur de Vlmitation, THOMAS A KEMPI8. 65 Beati Bemardi Saluberrimu de Imitatione Xpi et contemptu mundi quod Johanni Gerson . . . attribuitur." For many editions after this the name of A Kempis totally disappears. So much for the chain of evidence. But Dr. Thomson has told his readers that he fancies " Gersen'* was a mere misprint for " Gerson" ! Can it be so? In the year 1638, years after Thomas of Saint Agnes and Jean Gerson had shared the honours of writing this excellent tractate, a little edition in 12mo. was published, carefully collated with ten MSS, in which the book was boldly placed to the score of John Gersen, Abbot of Ver- ceil. Here is the title : — " De Imitatione Christi libri iv. per Franciscum Val- gravium Angl. benedict. ... J. Gerseni Abbati Ver- cellensi, italo benedictino ex dena manuscriptortim fide vindicate, Lutetise, 1638." Here the English Benedictine vindicates the existence of the Italian Benedictine, whom Andrew Thomson, D.D., has so kindly endeavoured to annihilate, or rather to iden- tify with the Parisian Chancellor. The fact is that Jean Gersen of Canabaca, or Cabaliaca,* was Abbot of a Con- vent of Benedictines in the thirteenth century, from the year 1220 to 1230 ; and he seems, says M. Monfalcon — who, perhaps very naturally after all, sums up in favour of his own countryman, and against the Piedmontese monk — '" to have much more legitimate right to be con- sidered the author of the Imitation than A Kempis him- ♦ Now Cavaglia, in the Vercellais (Piedmont). F 66 VAEIA. self. For, unless we adduce barbarous Latin (and Italian- ized words can be set off against Germanized words), the " Imitatio " presents no internal proof of a German monk haying written the book, whereas Gersen has one special proof which argues in his favour, and equally against A Elempis and Gerson." This was pointed out by Father Ganganelli, who died as Pope Clement XIV.* " What has made," wrote Ganganelli to his friend, a Canon of Orsino, " the Imitation of Jesus Christ so valuable and affecting is, that the author (Gersen, Abbe of Yerceil, in Italy) has transfused into it all that holy charity with which he himself was divinely animated. " Gerson is commonly confounded with Gersen ; never- theless it is easy to prove that neither Gerson nor Thomas h, Kempis were the authors of that matchless book ; and this, I own, gives me infinite pleasure, because I am de- lighted with the thought of such an excellent work being (having been) written by an Italian. There is evident proof in the fifth chapter of the fourth book that it was not a Frenchman who wrote the Imitation. It is there expressed that the priest, clothed in his sacerdotal habit, carries the cross of Jesus Christ before him ; t iiow all the world knows that the chasubles (a kind of cope which * I am quite aware that many look upon these very letters of Ganganelli as forgeries ; but this does not invalidate the testimony of the citation, its evidence being internal. t '' Sacerdos sacris vestibus indutus . . Ante se crucem in casnla portat, nt Ghristi vestigia diligenter inspiciat, et sequi frequenter studeat." De Imit, Christi, lib. iv. cap. 5, sec. 3. Codex cte Advo- eoHsf steculi xiii. THOMAS A KEMPIS, 67 priests wear at mass) in France differ from those in Italy^ in this, that they wear their cross upon their hacks ; hut I will not write a dissertation, heing content to assure you that I am, payi(T9Ti" Renderings from the Polyglot edition of '* Like unto Christ." Lyons, 1841. 68 VABIA. English. Of course the Latin word, which is admirable, has been a stumbling-block to all translators. The first, Mayster William^ who puts forth his version, printed in London bj Wynkjn de Worde and Eichard Pinson, called it " The Imitation, or Following of Christ" Edward Hake,* of Gray's Inn, copied the title, and says that the original was first written by Thomas Kempise, a Dutchman, amended and polished by Sebastien Oastalio, an Italian, and Englished by Edward H. Mr. Thomas Kogers in 1584, William Page in 1639, cited by Dr. Watt in the Encyclopaedia Britannica as the translator, and Luke Mil bourne, who, in 1697, turned the book into quaint and sometimes good rough verse, followed Mayster William in his long and periphrastic name. Dean Stanhope, who has his faults as a translator, since ^^ il a mutile le texte ; tantot il I'abrege, tantot il I'etend outre mesure, et toujoura il en denature la couleur," — ^yet had sense enough to break away from the un-English Imitation, and called his ver- sion the " Christian's Pattern." And finally, in spite of the dictum of one of my reviewers, that my own version of the title is " impertinent," I have ventured to call it, in plain English, " Like unto Christ." In an age like the present, when we care more for the comfortable smToimdings of life than for anything else, to study this book, which has mainly been written with re- ference to the former, is a bold experiment ; but, because it is bold, it will be interesting. It will be like walking * The ImitatioD, or FoUowiDg of Christ. London, 1567, in 8vo. THOMAS A KEMPIS. 69 in a cool room and a purer atmosphere afl^r being heated with the scents, music, fine dresses, exercise, and the other warm accessories of the ball-room. To read in a gold- seeking and self-seeking age of a man who looked upon wealth as a curse, who considered place a trial, and who thought the very friendship and society of women dan- gerous in the extreme — ^to read of such a one in an age which runs after the heels of the prettiest and most showy girl, which elevates her to a goddess and uses her as a toy, will at least be something novel ; for what must many of our ladies be when M. Dupin, at Paris, feels con- strained to publish a pamphlet '^ Sur U lAixe effrene des Dames'' — on the unbridled luxury (of dress) of women ? — when at Marseilles men band together not to marry till women grow less expensive ? — when virtue is laughed at if poor, and success, even of the most shameful kind, is honoured, or at least tolerated ? '' 'Sfou see that man : that's old Johnson of our square. Well, he managed the estates of three young clients, and somehow they grew poor, and he grew rich : d'ye see ? He's worth knowing, he is." Or your friend points out Simkins. " You know Simkins. What I don't know Simkins ? He made a lot of money in the Crimean war by selling putrid meat and bad hay ; not a bad dodge, eh ?" Such conversations as these are to be heard every day. In New York successful men are pointed out who have made money in like manner, " by fair dealing, if possible, but money by any means ;" and these are the new Democracy, abused by the Press, but envied by their fellow-citizens. In Paris a new 70 VABIA. aristocracy has sprung up, which depends upon speculation for its sudden fortunes, but which has in great measure supplanted the old titular and territorial nobility. It is an age of luxury and material wealth ; and nothing succeeds like success. The very name of asceticism has almost been forgot- ten. Our Quakers and Methodist religionists are losing their hold upon the world. Arts and manufactures have become luxurious, pleasing, and delightful. The new philosophy teaches us to enjoy the world ; to make the most of life, not to despise it ; to use the world, not to contemn it. Hence asceticism has grown out of fashion ; for the very spirit of asceticism demands us to control our passions, to throw away our luxury, to despise riches, place, and honours, and to exercise ourselves in hardness, want, endurance, and a noble poverty. Of all treatises on this religious art, dogma, or inten- tion, the work which passes under the name of ^* Thomas k Kempis" is surely the best and most fascinating. It is one which Dr. Johnson said '* the world had opened its arms to receive." It is as popular as ^'Eobinson Crusoe" or the "Pilgrim's Progress." It has been translated into all tongues, and many times over into French and English. It is called the "Imitation of Christ," the original title being " De Imitatione Christi ;" but, in a recent transla- tion, as has already been mentioned, in which there is a history of the work, and parallel Scripture passages proving the perfect Evangelical feeling therein, it is called " like unto Christ," because its purport is to teach the reader to THOMAS A KEMPIS. 71 aim at being as nearly as possible truly like our Lord in life and deed. From the date of the first appearance of the '^Imitatio" until now there have been, in all languages, perhaps three thousand editions; and yet no one knows with certainty who was the author. In fact, the latest English editor presumes that the book had many authors ; that it is so good, that the spirit of many men, each chastened by sorrow and purified by faith, added word after word, and passage after passage to " the priceless sentences of Thomas h Kempis," as the Eev. Charles Kingsley has called them. Everybody has praised the book. It is one which Soman Catholics claim, for its author was an Augustine monk, or a chancellor of a monastery — certainly a priest ; although it is as free from exclusiveness as the Bible itself. It was a favourite with Jean Jacques Eousseau, who wept over its pages ; and yet he was a man who detested Romanism — ^nay, Christianity itself. A version of it was edited by John Wesley, and read by WJiitefield, who abominated stage-players ; another version was put into verse by Bacine, the celebrated French dramatic poet; and a copy was carried about by Corneille, the great comic dramatist. Fontenelle, who wrote the ^' Plurality of Worlds," and who was suspected of Materialism, said that it was '' the most excellent book that ever proceeded out of the hands of man, the Gospel being of Divine original." Johnson loved the book. Vaughan, author of ^' Hours with the Mystics," says that it can be " appreciated with- out taste, and understood without learning," and that 72 VAIIIA. thousands upon thousands in castle and cloister have for- gotten their sorrows and dried their tears over its earnest pages. We have seen that, in the opinion of the Eev. C Kingsley, the sentences are "priceless;" in that of our greatest female writer, who assumes the name of George Eliot, they are inspired utterances, speaking to every soul and to every age. To come down to the very moment at which we write, the Literary Churchman, an organ of the High Church, calls it " this queen of all uninspired hooks ; this marvellous hook, which can how the hearts of men and women of every class and creed ;" and the Nonconformist newspaper speaks of it as the widest, most spread, and most excellent of all comforting works. And yet the spirit of this good hook is ascetic, distinctly and openly so. We have seen that the simple meaning of asceticism is merely the exercising of the hody and mind in devout things; hut at times it has included an obnoxious purpose — ^that is, a separation of oneself from the world. Whether good or bad in its effect depends much on its use or abuse. Half the people in the world — the poorer half — are forced into a kind of asceticism; their poverty exercises them against their will. Though the mills of God grind slovrly, Tet He grinds exceeding small. Few poor men can go through the mills of trouble, trial, and misfortune without being brought very nearly to the dust. But this asceticism has its dangerous side ; and able men, nay, good men too, have hated it. It produces, as a natural consequence, the monk's cell and the nun's THOMAS A KEMPIS. 73 cloister. It makes people put on strange dresses and purchase beads and crosses, whether thej be Hindus, Mohammedans, or Christians. It induces the monk to fast, and the nun to whip herself, and the Brahmin to clinch his hand for ever till the nails grow through the back of it, and his limbs are stiif and powerless. At Benares it makes men run iron hooks through their backs, and get others to whirl them round like cockchafers on a string. It forces some to abstain from meats or marriage, or any simple natural pleasures. It made St. Simeon Stylites live for thirty years on the top of a pillar, beseech- ing God daily, and nightly, and hourly, for pardon and grace, and to cry out that thrice ten years — In hangers and in thirsts, fevers and colds, In coughs, aches, stitches, ulcerous throes, and cramps — A sign betwixt the meadow and the cloud,-— Patient on this tall pillar, I have borne Rain, wind, frost, heat, hail, damp, and sleet, and snow. While my stiff spine can hold my weary head. Till all my limbs drop piecemeal from the stone. In the present day it causes people to believe that God delights in the discomfort of his creatures ; at any rate, that he pleasingly beholds them torment themselves; it makes us punish little children with Bible lessons they cannot comprehend, and terrify them with stories of Og, King of Bashan, Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, and visions of hell-fire ; it makes Sunday, dies Dominica, the sweet Lford's day, a dreaded Sabbath ; it interdicts the Sunday walk ; it glosses over and blots out the mercies of God with the roaring thunders of his wrath. 74 VARIA. Hence asceticism, which in itself is heautiful and need- ful, has been so misrepresented that men hate it. Gibbon, a man of colossal intellect, much fairness, and great learning, wrote thus of it : " The Ascetics who obeyed and abused the rigid precepts of the Gospel were inspired with a rigid enthusiasm, which represents man as a criminal and God as a tyrant. They seriously renounced the business and pleasures of the age ; abjured the use of wine, of flesh, and of marriage ; chastised their body, mortified their affec- tions, and embraced a life of misery as the price of their eternal happiness." It is in the last clause of the above sentence that the mistake of asceticism lies. If we are fools enough to demand, as Stylites does, " the white robe and the palm " for the self-inflicted mortifications, we then are judge and jury on ourselves. And, unfortunately, man will play those parts. He is good and saintly, pure and charitable, but he gets filled with spiritual pride. Hence upon works of asceticism is built the damnable doctrine of works of supererogation. You have punished yourselves in this world ; reward yourselves in the next. You have said so many aves to-day, you need say none to-morrow. You fasted last week ; you can feast this. There is the carnival, the farewell to flesh; and the dancing and junketings, when it may again be eaten. All this is flat against the words of the Apostles and Christ. The ascetics are upon the shifting sands of self-pleasing, even in the midst of their self-torments ; but happily we find little or nothing of this spirit in " Like unto Christ." THOMAS A KJEMPIS. 75 This author resemhles Bunjan in his treatment of the world. He looks upon it as vanity, as Solomon did ; as a huge Vanity Fair, as the Pilgrim did ; hut he goes on his way, and eats and drinks, and acts like a reasonahle crea- ture. All that he does is to lay down rules for our guidance under trial, and consolations for our sorrows under defeat. He tells a man not to harass nor to hamper himself, very much in the words of Marcus Antoninus or Seneca : *^ A pure, simple, steadfast mind is not distracted with many duties, hecause it does all things for the glory of God, and, in itself at ease, strives to he free from self-glory.'* He tells him, if he is young and sets to work to prepare him- self to be a man, to fight no baby's battle, no fool's fight. " Who has a harder battle than the man who tries to con- quer himself?" He reminds him that, after all, it does not much matter if he is not very clever or great, for " humble self-knowledge is a surer road to God than diving into the depths of science. Science, considered in itself, is not sinful ; nor is the knowledge of anything that is good ; it has been ordained of God : but the preference must be given to a good conscience and a holy life." And, in Wynkyn de Worde's translation, he asks what has become of all the learned men long dead : *' Where be now all the royal poets, with their craftily conveyed poems ; and elegant orators, with their orations garnished with elegancy ; the philosophers, with their pregnant reasons and sentences ?" And the author finishes by assuring us, "^ Truly learned is he who does the will of God, subduing also his own desires." 76 VAIIIA. The prudential maxims of the writer are very well worthy of heing laid to our heart. A young man is not to open his heart to everyhody ; to he " no fawner towards the wealthy, nor to he fond of heing seen with great people ;" and he is to '' exercise charity towards all, hut intimacy with very few." To grow in spiritual progress, a man is especially warned not to interfere with other people's husiness, not to trouhle himself with the sayings or doings of others, with what this one says, and that one thinks. Those matters do not concern us. " How is it possible," asks the author, '^for a man to remain long at peace who intermeddles with other people's cares, who seeks occasions of dis- quietude abroad, and never examines himself ^t home?" How, indeed ? If we were " more intent upon self-im- provement, and less troubled about the outer world, then we might make some advance in wisdom." He tells us elsewhere that we should learn early to submit; trouble not ourselves who is on our side or who is against us ; that we should humble ourselves, and think ourselves chiefly in the wrong ; and that, unless we feel that we know worse of ourselves than of any others, we shall not he making much progress to the perfect life. If we want to play the peace-maker, we are to be at peace at home. The peace-maker is more useful than the learned ; for, " while the man of violence and passion turns even good to evil, he who follows peace turns evil to good ;" and so, there- fore, we are to be peaceful and gentle, and to avoid quar- rels, and to put up with slights and wrongs, and we shall be happy. THOMAS A KEMPIS. 77 "We are advised not to meddle with others, not to be in- quisitive ; for '^ what is it to thee whether a man does such and such, or says so and so ? Thou art not required to answer for others, but for thyself." We are not to care nor to follow fame, nor the friendship of many, nor the regard of men, for these things generate distraction and great darkness of heart. To be thoughtful, watchful in prayer, and humble at all times, will alone make a man as he should be. Of self-esteem we are told very truly, as most men know who have thought much, that we cannot place too little confidence in ourselves, for we are often wanting in grace and sense. ^' The light we have is but small, and that we often lose through negligence. Often- times our mental blindness we do not perceive ; ofbtimes we act badly, and then make matters worse by our neg- ligent excuses. We often think and weigh what we have to bear through others, but what they have to bear through us does not occur to us." As the author of this precious book lived before men thought much of the suggestion of Duns Scotus, which, little more than a dozen years ago, the present Pope ex- alted into a dogma, it is by no means a surprising thing that A Kempis is utterly free from Mariolatry. He relies, like the Articles of the Anglican Church, upon one Name only, and finds none other under heaven given to man save that of Christ. " The kingdom of God is within you," he quotes from St. Luke in the beginning of the second book ; " betake thyself then entirely to God : love TTinn with all thy heart, with all thy soul, and bid a 78 VARIA. final adieu to this wretched world, and thou shalt find sweet content and comfort unspeakahle. Learn to despise these outward vanities, and seek pure and spiritual satis- factions. Place all thy hopes, thy happiness, thy thoughts in them, and thou shalt find this kingdom grow up within thee, * for the kingdom of God is peace and joy in the Holy Ghost.' Eom. jdv. 17." This is Stanhope's trans- lation. It is worthy of remark, also, that there is hardly a page in the " Imitatio" without its ^ye or six references to or quotations from Holy Writ: a satisfactory proof that in the monastery, at least in those days, the Bihle was diligently and devoutly studied. Such are a few of A Kempis's priceless sentences taken almost haphazard. We have said nothing, for our space will not allow us, upon the religious heauty and fer- vour of the work. ^Readers will find religion host preached in the pages of the hook itself; and it is scarcely our pro- vince to preach religion, although it may he our husiness to point the way to happiness and peace. The whole inten- tion of the author or authors is to awaken man to his true relation with God, the highest Intelligence, and to keep him from Materialism, the lowest Intelligence. Thus wrote a true poet : — Our little lives are kept in equipoise By struggles of t-wo opposite desires — The struggle of the instinct that enjoys, And the more noble instinct that aspires. DR. JOHN FAUSTUS. »=S^ BOOKS CONSULTED. The ffistorie of the damnable life and deserued death of Doctor John FauMtus. Newly imprinted and in conuent placet amended: ac- cording to the true copie printed at Franckfort, and trantlated into English by P. F, GenU Scene cmd allowed. Imprinted at Lon- don by Thomas Orwin, and are to be solde by Edward White dwelling at the little North door of Paules, at the signe of the Gun. 1592. The Tragical historic of Dr. Faustus. By Christopher Marlowe. 4to. 1604. Histoire prodigieuse et lamentable de Jean FaustCf grand et horrible enchanteur, avec sa morte ipouventable* Demiere Edition. A RoveD, chez Clement Malassis. M.DCLXvn. Faustus : his Life, Death, and Descent into fftlL Translated from the German. By George Borrow (this is added in pencil). London. W. Simpkin and R. Marshal. 1825. Earlg English Prose Romances, with Bibliographical and Historical Illustrations, Edited by William J. Thorns, F.S.A. Vol. III. London. Nattali and Bond. 1858. Lives of Notorious Cfriminals, including that of Dr. Faustus. Chap> book. London, 1754. Die Geschichte vom Faust, in Reimen, nach dem eimigen bekamUen Exemplar wn 1587, in der KonigUchen Bibliotliek zu Koptnhagen: Die Deutschen VoUusbUcher von Faust und Wagner, 8^c, Yon I. Scheible. Stuttgart, 1849. Festus, a Poem, By Philip James Bailey. Sixth Edition. Chap- man and Hall. 1860. DR. JOHN FAUSTUS. fl HISTORY, or a legend, or a mkture of B both, which has not only ftirnished a, sub- U ject for " Marlowe's mighty line," but has ■ given to Goethe the plot of the greatest poem of the century, or, if wo believe some, of all time, is worth our attention. When, moreover, this history has become the eubject of as many volumes as would fill a goodly bookcase; when our children delight over that which horrified and astonished our great- great -grand- fathers, one feels that there must be in it an element of popularity which is as enduring as it is perhaps difficult to account for. How many, too, are there who merely know the name and nothing else of the hero. If, at a competitive examination, the question, " Who ivas Faustus, and nhen did he flourish?" were proposed, how few would be able to answer it. It is not every one who can go to Mr. Thoms's capital book on early English prose romances, or to the People's Wonder-Book of Herr Scheible, The history of Faustus is involved so much in doubt, and at 82 VARIA. the game time has so many points of interest for as, that it is worth while spending a few minntes over it. " Truth is great, and will prerail," is a grand asser- tion, and one which has often consoled the dying mo- ments of the martyr ; hut it will scarcely hear the calmer and closer investigation of the philosopher. Truth differs from truth, hut not more than it essentially differs from itself; for, as the well -cut hrilliant, when it comes from, the hands of the lapidaiy, has its sixty-two facets — thirty-three ahove the helt, and twenty-nine helow it — so each truth, after heing handled hy the historian, wouTd seem to have at least sixty-two aspects, or, indeed, as many more, perhaps, as there may he people to look at it. As history is, according to some, a mere collection of hiographies, biographical truth might be expected to be the simplest ; but, not excepting that of Shakespeare, of whom we know little more than the date of his birth, mar- riage, and death, there is hardly a name in the *' Biogra- phic Universelle " about whom writers have not wrangled so much as to make the earnest student repeat the question of him whom Bacon calls jesting Pilate, and turn away in disgust. The occupation of the writers of one age seems to be that of whitewashing the black sheep of a past one — an employment in which both Mr. Carlyle and Mr. Froude have made themselves conspicuous; and, as there was found, soon after his death, one hand at least which scat- tered flowers on the tomb of Nero, we may possibly soon meet with an eccentric historian who will prove that both that emperor and Caligula were men of the highest moral BB. JOHN FAUSTUS. 83 calibre^ and with reference to whom it were, at any rate, as well to entertain historic doubts. When a character has been well blackened, however, it is exceedingly difficult thoroughly to cleanse it. Notwithstanding Horace Wal- pole's cleyer tract, and the more acute suggestions of his successors, we doubt whether Eichard III. will not re- main to the end of all time the crook-backed tyrant of Shakespeare, and the politic scoundrel of our sohool his- tories. Many people are fascinated by the coloured and sparkling rays thus brightly thrown out by a polished and cut truth. A. university professor, in his inaugural lecture some short time back, fairly owned that he rather pre- ferred his early and more popular ideas, and that, although some great writer might arise who would under- take to prove that Henry VIII. was a mild gentleman, exceedingly ill-used by ladies who deserved their fate, he would still rather cling to his old faith in the embodiment of an historic blustering and hectoring Blue Beard. No doubt many share a like feeling. One of those characters about whose various biogra- phies there is just the smallest scintillation of truth, and who has now fairly become the property of fiction, is Dr. Faust, known with us as Faustus, a German scholar who flourished in the beginning of the fifteenth century, and who has been constantly confused with Fust, the assist- ant, or, as some say, the patron of Gutenberg, who in- troduced into Germany moveable types about the same period. John Fust, who was evidently the capitalist, joined with Gutenberg and Schoeffer, the inventor of the 84 VARIA. letter-punches^ and by a law-suit dispossessed Gutenberg of any benefit from bis discovery. Perhaps, therefore, any ignominy which may attach to his name he richly deserves ; in fact, the theory of many is that the illumin- ators, missal and psalter writers, who were beaten out of the market by his machinery, invented the legends concerning him — viz. that he was aided by a personal attendant, a friendly Devil, who, after serving him for a stated number of years, at length bore him quick to hell as a payment for his services. Now, although we have been expressly warned not to confound the two Fausts, we believe that they have already been inextricably confounded, and that what simply belongs to one has been asserted of the other. The Dr. Faustus was an astrologer and a chemist ; and it is certainly not unlikely that popular superstition may have gifted him with a " familiar," just as it did Polydore Vergil, Jerome Cardan, and Paracelsus; of this latter brag- gadocio chemist it is said that he had one confined in the pummel of his sword. It is notable, also, that Faustus's Christian name, like that of Fust, was Johann. The sub- ject of our sketch was bom at Knittlingen, in Suabia, of peasant parents. He studied at Wittenberg ; removed to Ingoldstadt, where he practised as a physician ; received a considerable inheritance; was known to Melancthon, Tritheim, and other men of note of the period; gave himself up to magic, and died of the plague, in 1466 — or, as tradition will have it, was carried away, as per con- tract — at a little village called Eimlich. For this latter, legendary occurrence, one or more villages, following the DB. JOHN FAUSTUS. 85 example of the seven towns which contest the honour of Homer's birthplace, put in a claim — especially Breda, in Saxonj, a small village on the Elbe, where the blood- besprinkled waHs of the apartment may be seen, and where, to quote Jack Cade's friend, the ^^ very bricks are alive to this day," to testify to the truth. ^^That this hero was no imaginary one," says Mr. Thorns, " is clearly proved by the testimony of contem- porary writers. Amongst the most important of these is the famous Trithemius, who, in a letter to Johann Wedunger, dated the 20th August, 1507, speaks of the subject of this notice as one ' qui se principem necromanticorum ausus est nominare, gyrovagus, battologus et circumcellio est,' and as having formed for himself this fitting title, ' Magis- ter Georgius SabeUicus, Faustus junior, Fons Necroman- ticorum, Astrologus, Magus secundus, Chiromanticus, Agromanticus, Pyromanticus, in hydra arte secundus.' In 1539 he is mentioned by Begardo, in his ^ Index Sani- tatis.' Gastius also alludes to him in his ' Sermones Con- viviales;' and he is also alluded to by Manilius in his ' Collectanea,' on the authority of Melancthon." Gones tells us that, though there is much conflicting evidence as to where he was bom and when he lived and flourished, there is little doubt of his being an historical personage, '^ and one who had wit to take advantage of the times in which he lived," and whose quicker wit ,and boldness saw through the superstitious fears of his countrymen and laughed at them. This quickness of wit and boldness of conception, this 86 VABIA. superiority to those around him, met with the not unusual reward of his being exalted into a wizard and of having dealings with the devil. Nay, like others, he, too, must have an attendant devil ; and Mephistopheles was called in early to serve him as a valet, and to transport him, for a due consideration, whither he chose, and as rapidly as possible. Thus he travels round the world in eight days, and sees all the glories, riches, and wonders thereof. So singular a story seems to have at once seized on the popular mind. It was quickly dramatized in Germany, and presented with the other monkish legends and plays ; and in thirty years from the time our own Marlowe had formed upon it a splendid work which had been acted with applause. Since that time, nearly fifty different poems and dramas have been built upon the story — two of the best, excepting, of course, Goethe's, being by Klingemann and Roder. Lastly, Goethe elaborates it into the most re- markable fiction of modern times, and one which is the chief corner-stone of his fame. A writer would, one might suppose, as soon think of re-writing Hamlet as of rehabilitating" Faust;" but, notwithstanding that we have thirty-three translations of Goethe's great work, a modem English poet, James Philip Bailey, has dared it in Festus^ and has spasmodically succeeded ; and a modem play- wright has yet more recently put the subject on the boards of the Princess's Theatre as Faust and Marguerite. What we now propose is, to give the old legend, with some of its blunt English padding, refeiiing now and then to " Marlowe's mighty line," to point out what people miss DB. JOHN FAUSTUS. 87 who neglect our elder dramatists. Marlowe had indeed a method of throwing ten syllables together in a way as for- cible and as original as any master of blank verse that ever lived. Dryden, a great writer, comes somewhat near him in force ; Webster and Dekker still more closely in rough and ponderous weight; Milton in majestic diction and splendid energy: but no one combines all so much as Marlowe himself in his best verses. But to return to our Doctor. The author of one of these little histories begins with a sage remark upon the difference between ignorance and knowledge ; and, after the good old manner of Pinnock in his histories, he dabs about ten lines of very bald verse on the top of his chapter, which he afterwards translates into prose, to the effect that we should not attempt to know too much, " as the events about to be recorded in this history will, in our opinion, unless we greatly err, fully evince." John Faustus, he continues, was bom in a small hamlet, in the province of Wiemar: his father was a poor labounng man, but his uncle, who lived at Wittenberg, " took the young Faustus and adopted him, and made him heir to his property. Thus, instead of being doomed to follow at the plough tail, to work early and late, and to live upon the most homely fare, our hero was destined to bask in the sunshine of affluence, to tread the flowery meads of learning, to drink at the im- mortal fount, to climb Helicon's bank, and thereby to reach the tenlple of fame. Young Faustus, now become the favourite of his uncle, who had a good living in his gift, was sent to study divinity at Wittenberg, the same place at which 88 VABIA, * Hamlet, Prince of Denmark ' was educated, and whicli is rendered immortal by the pen of om* unmatched Shakspeare." The '' good living " originated of course from the hand of our English chap>book maker; but all authorities agree that Faust went to "Wittenberg. " Son oncle, qui demeura k Wittenberg," says a French author; and an old ballad in one of the four thick squat volumes of nearly 1300 pages each, which Scheible has published in Das Kloster, opens with the following verses — Es ist der Doctor Faustns nun Gewesen eines Bauren Sun : ZvL Rodt ben Weinmar bUrtig ber, Zu Wittemberg so bat auch er Ein Freundschafft gross ; &c. &c. At this place '^ he prosecuted his studies until he had exhausted the stores of learning ; he regularly passed " all the various minor academical degrees with credit to him- self and honour to his tutors, and ^* was inducted into his uncle's living, and looked up to as a most impressive and orthodox preacher." But, alas ! — Tbe devil cunningly prepares, And for bis victims spreads bis snares ; Thus Faustus in a luckless bour Submitted was to Satan's power. The fact was, he " consorted with alchemists, a herd of im- postors, tlie disgrace of the age ;" and, determining to be the top of the tree, he consulted his oracles, wherein he '* found it was requisite to undergo a probation of forty days, during which he must five times every day invoke the DR, JOHN FAUSTUS. 89 Prince of Darkness, trample on the Bible, seclude himself from society, and drink morning and evening, repeating his diabolical lessons^ two spoonfuls of Devil's soup ; he drew a magical circle on the floor, then set with diligence getting together the materials of his infernal diet. . . • With no common degree of fortitude, he began to rummage the churchyards for bones of a particular description, in the hollows of which worms of a peculiar shape and colour had engendered ; he then procured newts of a month old, the eyes of dead brindled sows, eagles' eggs with five black spots on them, hoo& of cows that had died of the murrain, heads and legs of toads, spawn of frogs, genitals of scor- pions, tongues of crocodiles, livers of male black rats, toes of nightingales, brains of white boars above three years old, and spurs of game cocks ; the whole of this was boiled to a consistence with whale's sperm and snails, to which he added every morning seventy-three drops of his own blood, taken from his left arm by himself" ! Having concocted this devilish potion, which certainly by far exceeds the milder concoction in Middleton's Wit^ih or Shakespeare's Macbeth, he in all things conformed himself to his " proba- tionary state, tearing Bibles to pieces, and treading the scattered leaves under his feet. He soon knew that he was rapidly advancing to his desired aim, and having covered his head with a woollen cap, on which was painted a skull and cross-bones, together with a figure of the devil, he began to invoke the devil in Low Dutch." The next few pages of this imaginative history are filled with a description which would very well suit the 90 VARIA. celebrated scene in Der Freischuiz, Faustus is surrounded by all kinds of terrors. He drinks the soup, and dances on the leaves of the Bible ; he hears the very thunders of Hell, sees a frightful dragon with a " three-pronged pitch- fork,'' a hare chasing a lion, a hyena swallowing little children, and a little man with a cocked hat, who says, " Friend Faustus, my master, Lucifer, has sent me here to ask what wantest thou ?" to whom Faustus truculently replies that *^ he wants his master, and would see him, if he were buried in fifty hells deeper than he is*" The messen- ger disappears, the hurly-burly recommences, and a great ball of fire runs round and round the circle with incredible velocity, from which a voice of thunder cries out, " Mortal, what wantest thou ? " The Doctor, nothing daunted, " recruited himself with a spoonful of soup," and challenged the Devil to come forth, upon which the ball of fire opens, and Beelzebub enters on the scene. The clever Doctor fancied that he had outwitted the Prince of Darkness, for, when the latter asked him to be his, " body and soul," for ever, Faustus said, " Nay, I will not ; I will have all I desire of thee, but will not be damned." Upon the Fiend putting this little matter in the right way, he receives the skin of a human body ; upon which he agrees to make out certain requisitions, and a conveyance of his body and soul to the Devil. He goes home to his study, and diligently draws out these articles, of which there are nine. The Devil is to be at his command, to do his bidding, to give him exhaustless wealth, to render him invisible, to convey him anywhere in one moment, to DR. JOHN FAUSTUS. 91 raise the dead or bring before him any living person, to show him the interior of hell, and, finally, " to lay aside his devilish propensity for lying, and when questioned tell me nothing but the truth. (Signed) John Faustus." The Devil soon, in an awful clap of thunder, sends up a series of replies, in which the chief requisitions are granted, but in which the last assertion is very positively denied : — ** I will answer all your questions truly : the world does me injustice to tax me with want of veracity ; let them ask their conscience if I ever deceived them, or made them believe a bad action was a good one ? " A shrewd question truly ! " Moreover" (the deed concludes) " I hereby promise to let my trusty servant, Mephistoph^les, be ever at your call, and further, allow you twenty-four years to enjoy the privileges purchased at so dear a rate. " Signed, by order of Lucifer, Prince of the Hellish Regions ; by us. Judges of his Infernal Domain ; and in his name we say Amen, it shall be so. " Rhadamanthus. " Minos. Here, again, is that mixture of Paganism with modem belief which seems so necessary for the poet. We should scarcely have dreamt of the Homeric and Virgilian judges serving under the Hebraic Satan. Que vouhz-vous ? there are none other witnesses at hand. The bonds being ex- 92 VABIA. changed, Mephistopheles is assigned to Faustus. He pre- sents his new master with one of the keys of Hell, say- ing : — " Take this : its possession is a favour never before granted to mortal. Whenever you wish to see me, if you hold up this key above your head, and say, Olishmaramotk Teufely I shall instantly appear in the shape you now see me ;" which was that of a dapper little man dressed in black, very much like a French abb^ . Next we find related many of the doings of Faustus, scarcely worth repeating. He was, we are told, a man of some humour ; and he shows it much in the same manner as some of our fast young men would do. He set all the cocks in Wittenberg crowing for three hours without intermission, and once, ''just as the parson had mounted the pulpit," got all the pigs within six miles to come to church — such a grunting and squeaking being never before heard. Many of these tricks we must put down to the English fancy of the poor scribe who vamped up this book. One day he makes all the old maids of Wittenberg, " each with a penny pie and a tabby cat," walk on one side of the street, and the old bachelors on the other. At another time, " at a grand levee held by the Emperor of China," all the Mandarins and nobles began hissing at and thumping each other ; and when the Emperor blew his nose, he blew out — not his brains, as the American story has it — ^but nothing but butterflies and worms. Faustus sets the '' Great Mogul " and all his court sneezing; and at a sumptuous repast given to the Emperor of Persia he causes all the wine to flow from decanter to glass con- tinually. He makes almanacs — ^here we are reminded of DR. JOHN FAUSTU8. 93 the Doctor — ^and is more successAil than our own Professor Murphy ; for what he predicted, rain, hail, frost, or snow, invariably occurred. He wishes to marry, but a fiend with a fearful name, '^ Ghasthomio," gives him such a whipping with hot wires and scorpions that he repents. Marriage, the fiend says, is a holy state, but yet he may have his desire in another way. He asks where Hell is, and receives in the answer a curious melange of the Hebrew Gehenna and the classic Tartarus. It is probable that we never shall escape the bondage of these ideas : even the wonderful imagination of Dante is constrained to adopt them. But the splendid diction and the atmosphere of Protestant thought in which Marlowe lived saved him from this ; and to the same question Mephistopheles replies with a fine anticipation of that subjective view of Hell of which we have a good deal at present : — Hell hath no limits, nor is circamscribed In one self place ; but where we are is hell ; And where hell is there must we ever be. And, to be short, when all the world dissolves. And every creature shall be purified, All places shall be hell that are not heaven. << I think there be no such place as hell," says Faustus, superciliously ; and his attendant is glad that he thinks so till he is fully entrapped. Mr. George Borrow indeed makes the Devil turn the tables on man, and say, with some humour, as the concluding sentence of his ghastly book : — "When men wish to represent anything abominable, they paint the Devil ; let us, therefore, in revenge, when 94 VAEIA. we wish to represent anything infamous, depict man ; and philosophers, popes, priests, conquerors, ministers, and authors (!) shall serve us as models." Hell is, however, not long a matter of douht to the Doc- tor, for he visits it ; while, previously to this visit, Mephis- topheles had descrihed it thus : — " My Faustus, knowe that Hell is, as thou wouldest thinke with thy selfe, another world, in the which we have our being, under the earth, and above the earth, even to the heavens, within the circum- ference whereof are contained ten kingdomes — namely. 1. Lacus Mortis. 2. Stagnum Ignis. 3. Terra teuebrosa. 4. Tartarus. 5. Terra oblivionis. 6. Gehenna. 7. Herebus. 8. Barathrum. 9. Styx. 10. Acheron. The which kingdomes are governed by five kings — ^that is, LtLcifer in the Orient ; Belial in Meridie ; Astaroth in Occidente ; and Phlegethon in the middest of them all : whose rule and dominions have none end until the day of Dome. And thus farre, Faustus, hast thou heard of our rule and kmgdomes.'' We do not, in the old legends, find many hints towards the wonderful scenes which Goethe has created. The tricks of Faustus are clumsy and countrified, and on a par with the stories related in the " Hundred Merry Tales of Shakespeare." Of the wonderful scene in the cellar, illustrated finely by Eetzsch, and our own painter, Theo- dore von Hoist, there is this mere skeleton :— - DR. JOHN FAUSTUS. 95 " How Fausttis serued the dronken Olownes, " Dr. Faustus went into an Inne, wherein were many tables fiill of Clownes, the which were tippling kan after kan of excellent wine, and to bee short they were all dronken^ and as they sate so they sung and hallowed^ that one could not heare a man speake for them; this angred Doctor Faustus ; wherefore he said to those that called him in, marke my masters I will shew you a merry jest. The clownes continuing still hallowing and singing, he so conjured them, that theire mouthes stood as wide ' open as it was possible for them to holde them, and never a one of them was able to close his mouthe again : by and by the noyse was gone, the clownes not withstanding looked earnestly one upon another, and wist not what was happened ; wherefore one by one they went out, and so soon as they came without they were as well as ever they were; but none of them desired to goe in any more." This scene our English dramatist has followed, making each clown close his sentence with a filthy double entendre, no doubt for the purpose of tickling the ears of the ground- lings. He also makes "Fayre Helena" of Greece the mistress of the Doctor ; " for," says R. P. Gent, ** she was so beautifull and delightful a peece that Faustus could not bear to be one moment out of her sight." The Ger- man poem has a canto, the twenty-sixth, — ** Yon der Helena aua Grichenland ; ** and, indeed, so alluring a subject was not likely to be 96 VABIA. omitted by the book-makers. It is found in almost all the copies. Helen bears him a son, called Justus Faustus, but he, being a succiibiuSf disappears with his phantom mother. Here is the picture of the fair Helena, showed by Faustus to the students : " This lady appeared before them^ in a most rich gown of purple velvet, costly embroi- dered ; her hair hanging down loose, as fair as the beaten gold, and of such length that it reached down to her hams ; having most amorous cole-black eyes ; a sweet and plea- sant round face, with lips as red as any cherry ; her cheeks of a rose colour, her mouth small, her neck white as a swan ; tall and slender of personage ; in sum, there was no imperfect place in her; she looked round about her with a rolling hawk's eye, a smiling and wanton counte- nance, which near hand inflamed the hearts of all the students, but that they persuaded themselves she was a spirit, which made them lightly pass away such fancies." Very beautifully has Marlowe dramatised this scene of the legend. Helen is made one of the instruments of the fall of Faustus, and of his temptation by Mephistopheles ; and, indeed, the German doctor, upon the sight of this instrument of temptation, falls into a love ecstasy, and utters one of the most ardent and enthusiastic rhapsodies on beauty that was ever conceived. '* Was this fair Helen whose admired worth Made Greece with ten years* war afflict poor Troy ?'* asks the second scholar when he sees her ; but the Doctor speaks not so tamely. DB. JOHN FAUSTU8. 97 <* Was this the face that laanched a thousand ships. And burnt the topless towers of Ilium ? Sweet Helen, make me immortal with a kiss. Her lips suck forth my soul ! see where it flies ; Come, Helen, come, give me mj soul again* Here will I dwell, for heaven is in those lips. And all is dross that is not Helena. I will be Paris, and for love of thee. Instead of Troy shall Wittenberg be sacked ; And I will combat with weak Menelaus, And wear thy colours on my plumed crest. Tea, I will wound Achilles in the heel, And then return to Helen for a kiss. Oh, thou art fairer than the evening air, Clad in the beauty of a ihoutajid stars ; Brighter art thou than flaming Japiter, When he appeared to hapless Semele ; More lovely than the monarch of the sky, In wanton Arethusa's azure arms ; And none but thou shalt be my paramour !" It is worth our while here to glance at the following por- tions of a hallad, Eoxhurghe Collection (vol. iii. p. 280), which Mr. Thorns supposes may be a modernized version of one of 1588, "A Ballad of the life and Death of Doctor Faustus, the great congerer/' licensed to be printed bj the learned Aylmer, Bishop of London, and which it has been pointed out is very little more than an English version of the German Metrical Volksbuch, put forward at Tubingen by Alexander Hock, in the same year. The English ballad, of which we have printed a few verses, was sung to the tune of Fortune my Foe, a very popular one at the end of the sixteenth century. . H 98 VAEIA. The Just Judgment of God shew'd upon Br, Faustus, All Christian men give ear a while to me. How I am plung'd in pain but cannot see : I liv*d a life the like did none before. Forsaking Christ, and I am damn'd therefore. At Wertemburgh, a town in Germany, There was I bom and bred of good degree, Of honest stock, which afterwards I sham'd, Accurst therefore, for Fauahu was I nam*d. * In learning high my nncle brought np me, And made me Doctor of Divinity : And when he dy'd he left me all his wealth, Which cursed gold did hinder my soul's health. Then did I shun the Holy Bible book, Kor on God's word would never after look ; But studied the accursed conjuration. Which was the cause of my utter damnation. At last, when I had but one hour to come, I tum'd the glass for my last hour to run : And called in learned men to comfort me, But Faith was gone, and none could succour me. Then'presently they came unto the hall, Whereas my brains were cast against the wall ; Both arms and legs in pieces they did see, My bowels gone, there was an end of me. You conjurors and damned witches all, Example take by my unhappy fall : Give not your souls and bodies unto hell, See that the smallest hair you do not sell. DB. JOHN FAUSTUS. 99 But hope in Christ his kingdom you may gain, Where yon shall never fear snch mortal pain ; Forsake the Devil, and all his crafty ways, Embrace true Faith that never more decays. In the Faustus of George Borrow, which is a wild re- vengeful satire on Popes, Protestants, Kings, People, and Authors, we find that the Doctor visits England-^nay, in- deed, that he is more disgusted with our country than with any other. " Not all the charms of the blooming English- women could keep him any longer in this cursed isle, which he quitted with hatred and disgust, for neither in France nor in Germany had he seen crimes committed with so much coolness and impunity." As they leave the island, the Devil venfe a prophecy Mid gives an opinion on us English which, seeing that it is well to be despised of the Devil, one may venture to extract : — *' These people will groan for a time beneath the yoke of despotism, they will then sacrifice one of their kings on the scaffold of freedom, in order that they may sell them- selves to his successor for gold and titles. In hell there is very little respect paid to these gloomy islanders, who would suck the marrow from all the putrid carcases in the universe if they thought they could find gold in the bones. They boast of their morality and despise all nations, yet if you were to place what you call virtue in one scale, and vice with twopence in the other, they would forget their morality and pocket the money. They talk of their honour and integrity, but never enter into a treaty without a firm resolution of breaking it, as soon as a farthing can 100 VABIA. be gained bj so doing. After deatb they inhabit the most pestilential marsh in the kingdom of darkness, and their souls are scourged without mercj. None of the other damned wiU.haye anything to do with them. If the inhabitants of the continent could do without sugar and coffee, the sons of proud England would soon return to the state in which they were when Julius CaBsar, Canute of Denmark, and WiUiam the Conqueror did them the honour to invade them." Faustus visits the planets, and in Venus amongst other euriosities meets with women who do not spoil their figures by bearing children, but depositing eggs in the sun so hatch them. The Doctor runs through the usual vicious, foolish course, but at last the twenty-four years expire, and Mephistopheles in a jovial humour thus accosts him : — " Come, my Faustus, you have had your career, and a lewd and merry one it has been ; do not act the coward at the end." Which request is indeed of no more comfort than Jack Ketch offered to a highwayman. The Doctor, seeing no escape, gives a grand banquet, tells his friends his &te, and — *' As the clock struck twelve, the Devil and Gasthomio appeared ; Faustus made a stout resistance, uttering the most piercing cries, but the demons soon mastered him ; when the latter, taking him upon his pitchfork, flew away with him in a storm of thunder and hghtning." After this very bare prose, the poetry of Marlowe must DB. JOEN FAUSTUS. 101 strike everyone. When about to die^ the FauBtus of this great play utters this fine soliloquy : — O Faostiu ! Now hast thou but one bare hour to live, And then thou must be damned perpetually. Stand still, thou ever moving spheres of heaven. That time maj cease and midnight never come ; Fair nature's eye rise, rise again and make Perpetual day ; or let this hour be but a year, A month, a week, a natoral day. That Faustus may repent and save his soul. O lente lente eurriie nocti* egui! The stars move still, time runs, the clock will strike, The Devil will come, and Faustus must be damned. Then follows a scene of wonderful horror, extracted in the " Dramatic Specimens" of Charles Lamb, who speaks of it with a delicate and sweet appreciation. The soul of Faustus is borne away ; and in the morning the scholars find in his study his mangled limbs, which they gather up for decent burial, and as they go out the solemn chorus pronounces his epitaph : — Cut is the branch that might have grown fall straight And burned is Apollo's laurel bough That some time grew within this learned man. Faustus is gone ; regard his hellish fall Whose fiendfal fortune may exhort the wise Only to wonder at unlawful things, Whose deepness doth entice such forward wits. To practise more than heavenly power permits. Such is the story of our English Faustus. The legend in Germany seems so suited to the Teutonic mind that it 102 VABIA. will never be forgotten. The amount of literature, critical, descriptive, or romantic, expended on the legend is in itself prodigious. It seems that, as an embodiment of the history of one who yielded to temptation and finally paid the penalty of his weakness and wickedness, the story is admirably suited for the purposes of the satirist or the moralist, while the variety of scenes and the vast scope given for the working of the machinery of the romance have been at once perceived by the inventive and poetic minds of every age. Hence, starting from almost fresh standpoints, Goethe and Bailey have, in Faust and Festus, produced poems each of'which bears not only the impress of the author's mind, but also of the age in which he lived. " The intended theme of Goethe's Faust," says Coleridge, " is the consequences of a misology, or hatred and de- preciation of knowledge caused by an originally intense thirst for knowledge baffled. But a love of knowledge for itself, and pure ends would never produce such mis- ology, but only a love of it for base and unworthy pur- poses." Thus philosophically viewing the great cause, it is not to be wondered at, that before Coleridge had seen any part of Gt)ethe's Faust,* though of course when I was familiar enough with Marlowe's, I conceived and drew up the plan of a drama which was to be, to my mind, what the Faust was to Goethe's. My Faust was old Michael * ''The poem was first published in 1790, and forms the com- mencement of the seventh volume of Goethe's Schrifimy Wkn und Leipzigy bey S, Stad wtd G, J, GoicheTi, 1 790."— Cbferut^f '6te» bfi DB. JOHN FAUSTUS. 103 Soott ; a much better and more likely original than Faust." Coleridge then enters into a sketch of his plot, and the similarity between it and that of Goethe is remarkable. EGb hero does not love knowledge for itself — ^for its own exceeding great reward, but in order to be powerful. " This poison speck infects his mind from the be^nning." Alas, a poison speck infecting too many minds. Im- prisoned by the priests, and as he feels unjustly, for five years, he eyentually escapes and begins his great revenge. He turns to witchcraft, and at last tries to raise the devil, and the devil comes at his call. " My devil," writes Cole- ridge, ^^ was to be, like Goethe's, the universal humourist, who should make all things vain and nothing worth, by a perpetual collation of the great with the little in the pre- sence of the Infinite. I had many a trick for him to play, some better, I diink, than any in Faust." In the mean- time Michael is miserable, power does not bring happiness, and he has to keep the devil perpetually employed by im- posing the most extravagant tasks, but one thing is to the devil as easy as another. ^' What next Michael ? is repeated every day with the most imperious servility." In the end Coleridge had made Michael Scott triumphant, and '^ poured peace into his soul in the conviction of salva- tion to sinners through God's grace." Many are the works projected or dreamt of by the fertile brains of English authors, the non-completion of which we have sadly to regret, and not the least to be deplored is •this intended drama of Coleridge. One remark its study has won for us which is worth pondering ; his devil ^' makes 104 VAEIA. all things vain and nothing worth by a perpetual collation of the great with the small in the presence of the Infinite/' This is an old and yet ever new trick of the would-be philosophical sneerers^ and no one could have better ex- posed the sophistry of those who use it than Coleridge. But it is by no means yet played out; indeed we may imagine that in succeeding centuries Dr. Johann Eaustus will oft start up^ a fine modem gentleman, with old-new sneers at the priesthood, at a belief in goodness, virtue, and God ; and that Mephistopheles, shaped according to the fashion of the times, will captivate the minds of poetic youth, by his bold wickedness, his hardihood towards the Almighty, and his contempt of the creature of whose damnation he is the agent. As we look in the British Museum at the beautiful type, ink, and printing of the Mazarine Bible, so di£B.cult to an unpractised eye to be distinguished from a manuscript, which was the first production of Gutenberg and Johann Eaust, we can understand why the puzzled scribes and illuminators put their heads together to slander the pro- ducer. Not comprehending his process, they must have believed that the Devil aided one who could produce one hundred bibles or psalters in less than half the time in which they could produce one. May we not, then, fairly suppose that, after all, the printer and not the Doctor was the nucleus around which the most enticing fable of mo- dern times has been gathered ? Two facts are certain — both the Eausts lived about the same period, and both bore the same Christian name. QFEVEDO k«^ BOOKS CONSULTED. SttmondCs Higtorieal View of the LUeratwre of the South of Emnpe, Translated by Thomas Boscoe, Bohn, 1846. B